Would the Incredibles Be Considered Superheroes or Vigilantes in the Real World?

Have you ever wondered what it would be like if The Incredibles were real? Would the members of this super-powered family be hailed as heroes or would they be considered vigilantes by the general public and government? Let's explore this fascinating hypothetical scenario, drawing from the realistic portrayal seen in films like Man of Steel and Batman v Superman (BvS).

Public Perception of Superheroes

Although many people disliked the superhero films Man of Steel and Batman v Superman, these movies depicted a very realistic portrayal of how superheroes and supervillains would be received in the real world. The films consistently showed that, for the most part, superheroes would be feared by the general public until the public eventually came to revere them.

The Incredibles in the Real World

Let's imagine that the Parr family became real in the modern day. Bob Parr, or Mr. Incredible, would instantly be recognized for his incredible strength. He could easily lift vehicles and heavy objects with his hands and superhuman speed. His wife, Elastigirl, could stretch her body to escape danger, while their children, Dash, Violet, and Jack-Jack, would each possess unique superpowers, like super-speed, invisibility, and potentially telekinesis.

Superheroes or Vigilantes?

Given their extraordinary abilities, it is difficult to predict the initial reaction of the public. In a world where super-powered beings exist, there would likely be a wave of fear and suspicion. People may be frightened of the Parrs, especially considering their history of secret work for the government (under the guise of hero work). Could the Incredibles be trusted with such incredible power, or would they be seen as a threat?

The Role of Trust and Communication

Trust and communication would play a critical role in determining whether the public and government view the Incredibles as heroes or vigilantes. In the real world, the public would need to see that the Parrs use their powers for good and that they can be trusted to do so. They would need to be transparent about their intentions and actions. Conversely, if the Parrs were to act in ways that put the public in danger, or if they were to use their powers to enrich themselves, they would be seen as vigilantes.

Human Rights and Government Oversight

Another key factor would be government oversight and human rights laws. In the modern world, superhuman powers would challenge the existing legal framework, especially when it comes to human rights issues. Would an individual be allowed to use their powers for personal gain, or would there be a need for strict regulation and oversight?

Regulation and Legal Frameworks

Initially, the government might not have specific laws regarding superhuman abilities. However, as the presence of the Incredibles and other superpowered beings becomes more widespread, new legislation would likely be enacted. This could include laws regulating the use of powers, ensuring public safety, and protecting the rights of individuals with superhuman abilities.

Public Reaction and Media Influence

The media would play a significant role in shaping public opinion. Headlines, news broadcasts, and popular culture would influence how the Incredibles are perceived. Positive portrayals, such as the children helping each other, could humanize them and make them relatable. Alternatively, if negative media coverage exists, it could create a heightened sense of fear and distrust.

Community and Social Media Impact

With the rise of social media, real-time reactions and viral news could spread quickly, influencing public opinion. Positive community support and social media activism could foster a better relationship between the Incredibles and the general public. Conversely, if the media portrays the Incredibles negatively, it could create a wave of negativity and distrust.

Conclusion: A Balanced Perspective

While it is impossible to predict with certainty how the Incredibles would be treated in the real world, one thing is clear: their presence would significantly impact society. The initial reaction would likely be fear and suspicion, but over time, with the right actions and public communication, the Incredibles have a chance to be seen as heroes, protected by public admiration and support. However, any misuse or lack of transparency would result in them being labeled as vigilantes.

In the end, it all comes down to how they choose to use their powers and their commitment to the greater good. This is a fascinating scenario that challenges our perceptions of heroes, vigilantes, and the role of government in safeguarding the interests of the public.