Would a Classic TV Show from the 50s to 80s Survive on Modern Television?

The television landscape has evolved significantly over the decades, and what resonated with audiences back then might not appeal to contemporary viewers. Let's explore why shows from the 1950s to the 1980s wouldn't last a season today, focusing on the changing tastes and expectations of the audience.

Popular TV Shows from the 50s to 80s and Their Modern Relevance

One iconic show that introduced us to Tom Hanks was Get Real. In this darkly comedic series, two men dressed as women to live in a rent-stabilized apartment that only housed women. While it may have been thrilling for its time, it's doubtful that such programming would find favor with modern viewers. Our tastes and expectations for television have changed dramatically since then, making it difficult for shows from that era to break through today.

The Evolution of TV Show Viewerships

Television viewers evolve over time, and what was considered groundbreaking in the 1950s to 1980s might not hold the same allure now. For example, take the groundbreaking medical examiner series Quincy M.E. (1976–1983). The show offered a fresh take on how it approached crime solving and portrayed the medical examiner Dr. Quincy Jack Klugman with high-tactical and sex appeal.

Quincy M.E. and Its Modern Reboot

When the show first aired, it was revolutionary in how it presented crime solving from a medical examiner's perspective. The intro quickly sets the tone with a fresh, professional, and sex-appealing approach. Even the elements it showcased, like high-tech expertise and sex appeal, were a major draw. This show was more of a "guy thing" in the 1970s, which wouldn't translate well today.

CSI: Crime Scene Investigation (2000), a modern reboot of Quincy M.E., takes the same elements and runs with it. It's described as Quincy M.E. on steroids and at high speed. The style and pacing are more suited to contemporary tastes, making it highly unlikely that Jack Klugman could ever hope to compete with the energy and intensity of CSI.

Shows That Would Never Be Made Today

Perhaps the most notable show from that era that would never see the light of day today is Amos and Andy. This show featured characters based on caricatures of African-American stereotypes, which would be considered highly offensive and inappropriate today. It's a stark reminder of how far we've come in terms of representation and sensitivity.

Other Notable Shows

Remaining on the list of shows that wouldn't survive is Mr. Ed, a surreal comedy about a talking horse. While it was a hit in its time, it would be hard to justify such content in today's more sophisticated and politically correct media landscape. Similarly, My Mother the Car, a strangely comedic series where the protagonist's mother was reincarnated into a vehicle, would never fly today due to its cheesiness and outdated humor.

Another show worth mentioning is Hogan's Heroes, a military action comedy. While it might still be a hit in certain niches, its dated humor and limited character development would likely alienate a modern audience.

I Dream of Jeannie also faces scrutiny. The character of Captain Byrd, the astronaut character who referred to Jeannie as "Master," would certainly not be tolerated today due to the inappropriate use of power dynamics and racial stereotypes.

All in the Family: A Revolution in Television

Lastly, All in the Family was a groundbreaking show for its time. It dealt with serious issues such as racism, homophobia, and more, which were highly relevant and revolutionary at the time. While it's a great show overall, it's worth questioning whether Archie Bunker would be as well-received in today's society. The show's humor and depth are commendable, but the cultural and social norms have changed significantly.

In conclusion, the television landscape has transformed significantly from the 1950s to 1980s to today. While some shows might still find an audience, the majority would need significant updates or reimagining to survive in today's entertainment market. The key factors in making a classic show from that era work in today's environment include reinforcing contemporary social values, updating humor styles, and ensuring relevance and sensitivity.