Would Tommen Have Been a Good King if Not for the High Sparrow?

The hypothetical question of whether Tommen Baratheon could have been a competent and effective ruler under different circumstances is a topic of much debate among fans of the A Song of Ice and Fire series and the adapted TV show Game of Thrones. This article delves into Tommen's potential as a king, considering his character traits and the external influences that shaped his reign.

Innocence and Naivety

Tommen Baratheon is portrayed as a kind-hearted and innocent boy who often lacks the ruthlessness required for leadership. His naivety, while endearing, could have hindered his ability to make difficult decisions in a world filled with political intrigue and betrayal. This lack of experience could have led to mistakes in governance and decision-making.

Influence of Others

The series highlights how Tommen's reign is heavily influenced by his advisors, particularly the High Sparrow and his mother, Cersei Lannister. The High Sparrow's rise to power and subsequent political maneuvers significantly undermined Tommen's authority. If Tommen had been able to assert his own will and surround himself with advisors who respected his sovereignty, his leadership might have developed differently.

Desire for Peace

Tommen's genuine desire for peace and the well-being of his people is one of his strongest traits. This inclination towards diplomacy and negotiation rather than violence could have led to more stable governance if he had the right support. His efforts to stave off further war and strife reflect a vision for a more united and peaceful kingdom, qualities that are essential for a good king.

Lack of Experience

Tommen is younger and less experienced than some of the other key leaders in the series, such as his older brother, Joffrey, or Sansa Stark. His youth and inexperience made him vulnerable to manipulation, but with the right guidance and training, he could have matured into a more capable ruler. His interactions with characters like Margaery Tyrell, where he shows a willingness to learn and adapt, suggest that given the right circumstances, he had the potential to grow into a decisive leader.

Potential for Growth

Throughout the series, there are moments that indicate Tommen's potential for growth and development. His interactions with Margaery Tyrell, for example, show a desire to learn and adapt. If he had been able to find advisors who respected his authority and provided him with the wisdom and experience he lacked, he might have been better equipped to navigate his challenges.

Conclusion

In conclusion, while Tommen possessed the potential to become a good king due to his compassionate nature and desire for peace, his effectiveness was severely compromised by external influences, particularly the High Sparrow and the political chaos surrounding him. If he had been able to assert his authority and surround himself with wise counsel, he might have navigated his reign more successfully. However, the harsh realities of Westeros often favor cunning and strength over kindness, making it uncertain whether he could have thrived as a king.

Regardless of one's stance on this hypothetical scenario, Tommen’s character provides a rich tapestry for examining the complexities of leadership and the impact of external forces in a world where power and survival often come at great personal cost.