Would Samwell Tarly and Gilly Tarly Have Been Happier at The Wall with Jon Snow and the Wildlings?
Would Samwell Tarly and Gilly Tarly Have Been Happier at The Wall with Jon Snow and the Wildlings?
The complex query of whether Samwell Tarly and Gilly Tarly would have been happier living at The Wall with Jon Snow and the Wildlings involves delving into their characters, desires, and the circumstances they faced. This examination will explore the factors that make The Wall a potential utopia and a place of danger simultaneously.
Factors to Consider
Samwells Character
Sam is often depicted as a kind-hearted and loyal individual who struggles with his identity and self-worth. His journey in Game of Thrones highlights his need for companionship and a sense of belonging. At The Wall, he might find the acceptance and purpose he craves, especially in a community as diverse as the Wildlings. The Wildlings, known for their lack of judgment and emphasis on survival, could offer a sense of kinship to Sam.
Gillys Background
Having endured significant trauma and hardship, Gilly's relationship with her child, Little Sam, is a driving force. Her time with the Night's Watch, colored by the violence and mis treatment from her father, has made her yearn for safety and a stable environment. The Wildlings, with their strong family ties and values, could provide her with the security she has been searching for. Their emphasis on community and loyalty might offer Gilly the emotional stability she desperately seeks.
The Wildlings Culture
The Wildlings' way of life emphasizes freedom and survival. This lifestyle might appeal to both Sam and Gilly as it brings them away from the regulatory nature of the Night's Watch and the societal norms of Westeros. However, the harsh living conditions and constant threats from the environment and the potential conflicts with the Night King could also bring stress and danger. The constant vigilance required to survive could be emotionally exhausting.
Jons Influence
Jon Snow, as a leader and a bridge between the Night's Watch and the Wildlings, might provide a supportive environment for Sam and Gilly. His values of compassion and understanding could foster a sense of community. However, Jon's preoccupation with the larger battle against the White Walkers might mean that he is often away, leaving Sam and Gilly to navigate their challenges on their own.
Conclusion
Ultimately, while Sam and Gilly might have found a sense of community and support at The Wall, their overall happiness would depend on their ability to adapt to a life filled with challenges. The emotional support from Jon and the Wildlings could enhance their well-being, but the harsh realities of life beyond The Wall could present significant risks. Therefore, it is reasonable to conclude that they might have been happier in some respects but their overall happiness would be contingent on their circumstances and the challenges they faced.