Would Robb Stark Really Marry Margaery and Claim the Iron Throne?

Proponents of the idea that Robb Stark could marry Margaery Tyrell and eventually claim the Iron Throne often cite several factors. However, a closer analysis of their motivations, political strategies, and individual personalities reveals a much different picture. In this article, we explore why such an alliance is highly improbable and unpromising.

Aligning Interests and Political Goals

The Tyrells and Robb Stark's objectives diverge significantly. The Tyrells' ultimate goal is to replicate the influence of the Hightowers and the Lannisters, securing a strong hold on the Iron Throne to bolster their power and control over the continent. In contrast, Robb Stark sought independence for his homeland and justice for his father. His aspirations did not include becoming king for the sake of power or luxuries.

Robb's primary concerns were ensuring his father's land and people could thrive independently and seeking vengeance against those who wronged his family. His desire to sit on the Iron Throne was purely symbolic, not aspirational. The Tyrells would never allow such an arrangement to stand, as it would threaten their own ambitions and undermine their strategic dominance.

Political and Territorial Implications

The Northerners valued their independence and would not willingly become part of a larger kingdom, even if it meant the Crown remained intact. The Riverlands, although fertile, were strategically crucial for any claimant to the Iron Throne. Both Renly and the Tyrells saw a threat in allowing Robb to control these lands, as it would pose a significant challenge to their own territorial ambitions. This inherent conflict of interests would inevitably lead to conflict, not cooperation.

Bloodline and Legitimacy

Robb Stark's lack of direct bloodline to the throne further complicate any notion of his rightful inheritance. He was the only son of Princess Rhaelle Targaryen and grandson of King Aegon V. While Renly and Joffrey had claims based on alleged or true blood relations, Robb's lineage was more tenuous. To win the throne would require force, and given Robb's disinterest, such a path was unlikely.

Personality Clashes

Their stark personalities further reinforce why such a union and subsequent rule would be problematic. Robb Stark was a northerner in every sense—practical, resilient, and pragmatic. He valued honor, justice, and the welfare of his people. On the other hand, Margaery Tyrell was born and raised in the south, where luxury, politics, and intrigue were the norm. These differences would create a chasm in their relationship and governance style.

Even if Robb were to marry Margaery, their personal and political incompatibilities would make their union unstable. Their divergent worldviews and priorities would lead to frequent conflicts and a lack of common ground. This misalignment would hinder their ability to govern effectively, leading to potential civil unrest and further complications.

Strategies and Potential for Conflict

Robb Stark's military prowess is evident, but his top priority was maintaining Northern independence. His strategic focus would be on defending the North against Stannis Baratheon, making him a formidable opponent. Unlike Tywin Lannister, who achieved his victories through superior numbers and strategic alliances, Stannis was a seasoned military commander. Robb's Northmen would likely pose a significant challenge to Stannis, necessitating a cold war-like situation rather than direct confrontation.

Margaery, on the other hand, would likely prioritize political intrigue and consolidation of power for the Tyrells. Her ambitions would conflict with Robb's desire to keep the North independent and free. Their approaches to governance would be fundamentally different, making a cohesive and effective rule improbable.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the idea of Robb Stark marrying Margaery Tyrell and claiming the Iron Throne is fraught with contradictions and conflicts. Their divergent interests, incompatible personalities, and distinct approaches to governance would undermine any potential alliance. The Northerners' longing for independence and Robb's lack of direct lineage to the throne further complicate such a scenario. Ultimately, the political landscape of Westeros does not support the idea of Robb Stark's kingship, and any marriage alliance would likely end in failure and strife.