Would Jon Snow Make a Good King?

The question of whether Jon Snow would be a suitable king for the realm of Westeros has long been a topic of debate among fans and analysts. While he posesses admirable qualities, such as his inherent goodness, kindness, and honor, these traits alone may not be enough to make him a successful ruler.

Admirable Traits and Leadership Potential

On one hand, Jon Snow is undeniably a good person. His capacity for kindness and honor is evident both in the books and the show. This makes him an archetypal hero, with a strong sense of justice and mercy. Additionally, Jon's ability to forge alliances between different groups demonstrates his leadership skills and his ability to earn respect, even from his enemies. This respect likely played a significant role in protecting him earlier in the story.

Inherent Flaws and Challenges

Despite his many virtues, Jon Snow is not without his flaws. His sullen nature and quick temper can be detrimental to his leadership. He is also highly sensitive to perceived slights, which can lead to impulsive actions. Furthermore, Jon has struggled with effective communication in the past, which could be a major obstacle in governing a realm as complex as Westeros. He may find it challenging to navigate the intricate political and financial systems, particularly when dealing with entities like the Iron Bank.

Chosen One vs. Ideal King

It's often argued that Jon Snow fits the role of the "chosen one," a common trope in many fantasy series. His character aligns with the standards of many heroes—honest, noble, and determined. However, the reality of the situation is more nuanced. George R.R. Martin, the author behind the A Song of Ice and Fire series, provides ample evidence to suggest that the journey to kingship is fraught with complexity. Jon Snow would not be the worst king Westeros has ever had, but the question remains whether he would be the best.

Realistic Considerations

Jon Snow is a capable soldier and displays charisma, but these traits do not always translate to effective leadership. His sense of honor often impairs his judgment, and his difficulty in listening to advisers or bannermen might hinder his strategic decision-making. Additionally, his tendency to be overly honest and direct might leave him susceptible to treachery. In dealing with the Iron Bank or other powerful factions, Jon may struggle to maintain the delicate balance required for survival and success.

Conclusion

While Jon Snow has the potential to be an admirable king, his inherent flaws and lack of experience in the political and financial systems of Westeros could limit his effectiveness. The complexity of his character and the nature of the realm's challenges suggest that he may not be the ideal king. However, his role as a good humanitarian and his potential as a leader make him a significant and noteworthy figure in the story of Westeros.

Where do you stand on the question of Jon Snow as a king? Share your thoughts in the comments below.