Will Brienne Bear Jaime’s Child in the Books?

The question of whether Brienne of Tarth and Jaime Lannister will bear a child together has sparked much debate among A Song of Ice and Fire fans. While the Game of Thrones TV series did not explore this relationship, the books offer a much richer and more complex narrative context, especially considering the work of George R.R. Martin (GRRM).

George R.R. Martin and Legacy

GRRM is deeply invested in the legacy of his characters and the continuation of their families. His approach is different from other authors who may prioritize short-term plot devices over long-term character development. From the first book, GRRM has been laying the groundwork for each major house to endure in some form. For both Jaime and Brienne, hints of rule and parenthood abound. However, whether they survive to see these moments is highly uncertain, as GRRM has already stated that some characters' fates will diverge from the show's.

Platonic Relationship and Fate

Many fans believe that any relationship between Jaime and Brienne will remain platonic. In fact, it's very likely that Jaime will die in the books. This conclusion is based on numerous foreshadowing elements and GRRM's previous statements regarding character fates. The GRRM universe often leaves audiences hanging and the uncertainty adds to the intrigue and emotional investment.

Parental Aspirations and Jaime's Redemption

Brienne’s journey includes the pursuit of her own knighthood and the leadership of the Kingsguard. The idea of her becoming a mother to Jaime’s child is highly unlikely, given the serious foreshadowing of her future. If she were to somehow conceive, the child would likely face a difficult existence. However, the act of writing about Jaime, the flawed but good knight, and becoming the first woman in the Kingsguard would altogether transform how future generations perceive Jaime. His redemption would be a symbolic act of resilience and honor, rather than a biological one.

Biological Unlikelihood and Character Development

Beyond the plot’s symbolic implications, the biological aspect is also worth considering. Pregnancy is a major and rare occurrence, even in ideal circumstances. In reality, women do not conceive every time they have unprotected sex. This biological reality underlines the improbable nature of a potential pregnancy between Brienne and Jaime. This is a concept that writers often overlook in favor of dramatic plot devices or symbolism.

Conclusion

Given the complex narrative and personal development depicted in the books, it is highly unlikely that Brienne and Jaime will bear a child. The symbolic and emotional impact of their relationship, as well as the broader narrative arcs GRRM has established, make such a development less probable but not impossible. Regardless, the exploration of their relationship and the challenges they face—whether it leads to a child or not—adds immense depth and richness to the storytelling.