Why Contemporaneous Bollywood Lacks Musicians like Kalyanji-Anandji and Shankar-Jaikishan?

The perception that there are no good music directors in Bollywood today like Kalyanji-Anandji or Shankar-Jaikishan can stem from several factors.

Changing Musical Trends

The music landscape has significantly evolved over the decades. The styles and genres popular in earlier eras, such as the orchestral and melodic compositions of Kalyanji-Anandji and Shankar-Jaikishan, have shifted towards more contemporary sounds, including electronic music and fusion genres. This evolution reflects changing audience preferences and technological advancements.

Industry Dynamics

The Bollywood music industry has become more commercialized with a focus on singles remixes and collaborations that cater to current trends. This can sometimes overshadow traditional composition styles that characterized earlier eras. The rise of popular music genres like hip-hop, EDM, and pop has led to a shift in focus, often to the detriment of the classical and traditional styles.

Nostalgia and Fan Sentiment

Many fans have a nostalgic attachment to the music from the golden age of Bollywood, which can lead to a biased view of contemporary music directors. The emotional connection to classic hits often overshadows newer compositions, regardless of their quality. Moreover, the decline of live concerts and the rise of online music consumption can deepen this sentiment gap, as older music becomes more easily accessible and prominent.

Emerging Talents and Innovative Approaches

While some might feel that there are no equivalent music directors today, there are many talented composers in the industry such as A.R. Rahman, Pritam, and Vishal-Shekhar who are creating impactful music. Their styles may differ from earlier composers, but they bring innovative approaches to music production. A.R. Rahman, for instance, known for his intricate soundscapes and fusion of traditional and modern elements, has won numerous awards and created a unique style that resonates with contemporary audiences.

Diverse Influences and Eclectic Sounds

Modern music directors often draw from a wider range of global influences, leading to a more eclectic sound. This diversity can sometimes make it harder to compare them directly to the classic composers of the past. Musicians like Prasoon Joshi and Rohit Sopory, while adhering to traditional Indian music, also infuse their work with contemporary elements. This variety in approach ensures that music remains dynamic and engaging for contemporary audiences, who are exposed to a broader spectrum of genres through digital streaming platforms.

The Impact of Digital Platforms

The rise of digital streaming platforms has changed how music is consumed and promoted. While digital platforms provide a wider reach and more opportunities for exposure, they can also affect the visibility of certain composers and their work. Unlike the era of Kalyanji-Anandji and Shankar-Jaikishan, where music was primarily distributed through records and cable television, digital streaming allows for instantaneous access and can sometimes overshadow the artistic craftsmanship that these earlier directors were known for.

In summary, while the landscape of Bollywood music has changed, there are still many talented composers today who are making significant contributions to the industry. However, these contributions often come in different styles and contexts than those of Kalyanji-Anandji and Shankar-Jaikishan. The evolution of the industry and changing audience preferences are key factors in understanding why there might be a perception of a decline in quality.