Why the Uniform Designs in Star Trek: Discovery Differ from The Original Series

Introduction

While Star Trek: Discovery, first aired in 2017, is set a mere decade before Star Trek: The Original Series (TOS), which aired from 1966 to 1969, the uniform designs of Discovery are strikingly different. This raises several questions regarding the visual modernization, artistic direction, narrative context, and character development behind the new uniform designs. This article aims to explore these reasons and their implications within the context of the Star Trek franchise.

Visual Modernization

The primary factor behind the distinct uniform designs in Discovery is the emphasis on visual modernization. The creators of Discovery sought to appeal to contemporary viewership by updating the visual aesthetics of the franchise. This modernization process included not only the look of the uniforms but also the starships and technology. However, this updating often leads to inconsistencies when compared to earlier designs.

Artistic Direction

Another significant factor is the artistic direction unique to each series in the Star Trek franchise. Discovery was produced with a distinctly detailed and sophisticated design approach, reflecting current trends in television production such as higher budgets and advanced special effects. This approach is different from the relatively basic and utilitarian designs of TOS, which were more modest in comparison.

Narrative Context

Discovery is set roughly about ten years before TOS and during a period of significant change in the Federation. The show explores themes of conflict and evolution, which are reflected in the more militaristic and complex designs of the uniforms. These uniforms are not as simple and utilitarian as those seen in TOS, catering to the show's narrative needs.

Character and Story Development

The uniforms in Discovery are also designed to represent not only the characters' roles but also the evolving nature of Starfleet itself. The show's diverse cast and complex narratives may require more visually distinct uniforms to convey different factions, ranks, and identities. This uniform variety is essential for the rich storytelling of the series.

Retconning and Canon Stability

The Star Trek franchise has a history of retconning certain elements to fit new stories and ideas. While this can lead to some inconsistencies, it also provides the creative freedom needed to revitalize the franchise without completely discarding previous designs. The design choices in Discovery reflect a desire to create a fresh narrative while still honoring the legacy of the franchise.

It is important to note that periods in the franchise's timeline with rapid uniform changes are often linked to the creation of new shows or movies that introduce new technologies and design philosophies. Conversely, during periods not covered by television or movies, uniform designs can remain consistent for decades, as seen with the Monster Maroons that transitioned from TOS movies to Jean-Luc Picard and Jack Crusher.

The uniform designs in Discovery, while differing from TOS, serve to create a distinct visual identity for the series. These differences, when viewed within the context of evolving artistic choices and narrative needs, are largely justifiable and contribute to the rich tapestry of the Star Trek universe.

Conclusion

The uniform designs in Star Trek: Discovery, while starkly different from those of The Original Series, are the result of deliberate artistic and narrative choices. These choices reflect the franchise's evolution and desire to appeal to contemporary audiences. As fans, it is important to embrace this diversity and appreciate the unique visual identity of each series within the Star Trek universe.