Why the Edward Norton Hulk Film is Considered Canon and Not the Eric Bana One
Why the Edward Norton Hulk Film is Considered Canon and Not the Eric Bana One
Despite the fact that Universal holds the distribution rights over the character the Hulk, the Incredible Hulk (2008) featuring Edward Norton is often considered as part of the MCU canon. This is due to the production company, post-credits scenes, and the integration with the broader narrative of the Marvel Cinematic Universe. Conversely, the Hulk (2003) starring Eric Bana is not seen as part of the same canon. Let's dive into the reasons behind this.
Production under Marvel Studios
The Edward Norton Incredible Hulk was produced by the Mara Studios, a key distinction that sets it apart from the Hulk (2003) with Eric Bana. Only films produced by Marvel Studios and opening with a “Marvel Studios” not just “Marvel” logo are considered part of the MCU canon.
Post-Credits Scenes and Marvel Cinematic Universe Integration
The Incredible Hulk integrates seamlessly into the MCU, thanks to its post-credits scenes featuring William Hurt as Dr. Bruce Banner’s mentor Robert Bruce Banner and Robert Downey Jr. as Tony Stark, signaling the connection to the Avengers film. Banner in Avengers refers to the time he “broke Harlem,” further cementing his role within the larger Marvel ecosystem. Conversely, the Hulk (2003) with Eric Bana does not have these seamless connections or integrations.
Musings on the Edward Norton Hulk vs. Eric Bana Hulk
Edward Norton’s Hulk is often celebrated for its intensity and emotional depth. Norton's portrayal of Banner/Hulk is formidable and captivating, unlike anything we saw in the Hulk (2003). Fans and critics alike often harken back to Edward Norton’s rather than Eric Bana’s version. While Mark Ruffalo’s addition to the MCU in later films is equally valuable, Norton’s Incredible Hulk will forever hold a special place in the hearts of many fans.
The Reboot and Canonization
When the Hulk (2003) starring Eric Bana was made, it only existed as an individual film, not as part of a larger universe. However, its integration into the MCU through the Edward Norton film and subsequent post-credits scenes made it a reboot. The concept of a reboot in the context of film adaptations means the development of a new backstory that renders the previous one invalid. This is precisely what happened with the Hulk. The Edward Norton film became the rebooted version of the earlier one, making it the official canon version within the MCU.
Conclusion
The differences between the Edward Norton Hulk and the Eric Bana Hulk in terms of canon status lie in their production, integration with the MCU, and the emotional depth brought by Edward Norton's portrayal. While both are iconic in their own right, the Edward Norton version of the Hulk is more aligned with the overarching narrative and emotional journey of Banner and his transformation into Hulk.