Why Zack Snyder, Not the Scriptwriters, Is Blamed for DCEU's Flaws

The perception that Zack Snyder is primarily blamed for the issues within the DC Extended Universe (DCEU) can be attributed to several influential factors. This article will explore why Snyder's role and vision dominate the public discourse, rather than the scriptwriters' contributions.

Directors' Vision and Its Impact

As the director of key films like Man of Steel, Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice, and Justice League, Zack Snyder's vision and style significantly shape the overall tone and direction of the DCEU. His darker, more serious approach contrasts with the lighter tones of other superhero films. This stark contrast has led some fans and critics to view his work as a central cause of the DCEU's mixed reception.

High Profile Role

Directors typically receive more public attention and scrutiny than screenwriters. Snyder’s prominent role in the DCEU and his strong creative influence make him a focal point for both praise and criticism. His status as a well-known figure in the film industry amplifies this scrutiny, making him a more visible target for audiences and critics alike.

Controversial Storytelling Choices

Snyder's storytelling choices, such as the portrayal of characters, narrative structure, and thematic elements, have sparked significant debate. For example, the portrayal of Batman and Superman in Batman v Superman was divisive, leading to a backlash that some attributed directly to Snyder's interpretation. These choices often overshadow the contributions of the screenwriters who may not be as well-known or publicly discussed.

Fan Reactions and Community Engagement

The DCEU has a passionate fanbase, and fan reactions play a crucial role in shaping public opinion. Backlash against Snyder’s films often stems from disappointment in how beloved characters were adapted. For many fans, Snyder’s decisions overshadow the contributions of the screenwriters, who might not receive the same level of public recognition.

Cultural Impact and Fan Movements

The release of the Snyder Cut of Justice League in 2021 further polarized opinions about Snyder’s role in the franchise. Fans rallied for the release to see Snyder's original vision, which rekindled discussions about his influence on the DCEU. This fan-driven movement brought Snyder and his strategies back into the spotlight, even more than the under-the-radar scriptwriters.

Franchise Consistency and Leadership

The DCEU has faced criticism for its inconsistency in tone and quality across different films. Since Snyder set the foundation for the DCEU, any perceived shortcomings are often linked back to his leadership. This continuity in creative vision often leads to fan disappointment, particularly when a director's distinctive style is perceived as diverging from the established tone or quality of the franchise.

While screenwriters play a crucial role in shaping the story and dialogue, Snyder’s high-profile position and the distinctiveness of his directorial style make him a more visible target for criticism. This article underscores the complex relationship between directors and screenwriters in shaping the DCEU and how public perception often centers on the director's vision rather than the collaborative storytelling of a larger team.