Why Western States Can't Form Their Own Country: Legal and Practical Obstacles

The idea of Western states forming their own country or independent nation has sparked discussions among citizens and policymakers. However, several legal, economic, and practical reasons suggest that this vision remains elusive. This article explores these obstacles and the constitutional framework that so far has prevented Western states from embarking on such a path.

Legal Framework and Historical Precedents

The legal landscape surrounding secessionism is clear and well-established. The U.S. Civil War, which concluded in 1865, secured federal supremacy and the constitutionality of the Union. Following the war, the U.S. Supreme Court further reinforced this stance in the Texas v. White case, where it held that secession was unconstitutional.

These legal precedents are still pertinent today, providing a strong deterrent against any effort to form a separate Western nation. The U.S. Constitution, which outlines the structure and powers of the federal government, clearly states that the United States of America is to remain a single and indivisible nation. The will of Americans, both as individuals and as a collective, further reinforces this unity.

Practical Obstacles and Deal Breakers

Despite the theoretical possibility of a Western country, several practical challenges make such a realization highly improbable. One of the primary hurdles is the inability to form a constitution that both parties can agree upon. Key points of contention include universal single-payer healthcare, sensible gun laws, no gerrymandering, no elected judges or law enforcement officers, and a Westminster parliamentary system. Additionally, campaign and election reform, particularly regarding campaign financing, adds another layer of complexity.

Economic and Defense Relevance

Another significant barrier to forming an independent Western state is economic interdependence. While the West Coast has an economy capable of sustaining itself, defense remains a critical issue. The region heavily depends on the United States military for security, as evidenced by the presence of numerous military and naval bases. These bases play a crucial role in the local economy, providing jobs and economic stability. Without this military support, the region’s economic viability could be severely compromised.

US Global Dependence

Dependency on the U.S. military and defense mechanisms is not the only issue; the region's economy is also heavily reliant on the country as a whole. Key ports such as Los Angeles and Long Beach, which serve as gateways for international trade, are vital for the region's commerce. Severing ties with the U.S. in terms of trade and defense would be disastrous, making the idea of forming a separate Western nation economically impractical.

Political and Security Concerns

Political and security concerns also weigh heavily against the formation of a separate Western state. U.S. citizens, including those in the West, are deeply invested in maintaining the Union. There have been attempts to secede in the past, such as the California independence initiative, which faced overwhelming opposition. Historical precedents and political culture strongly discourage such movements, ensuring stability and continuity.

Moreover, there is significant resistance to any attempts that could be seen as divisive. Russian involvement in past independence movements further highlights the need for unity and stability. Support from external actors can be seen as destabilizing and could lead to damaging consequences for the region and the country as a whole.

In conclusion, the legal, economic, and political obstacles make the idea of Western states forming their own country highly unrealistic. The U.S. Constitution, historical precedents, and the interconnected nature of the economy and security ensure that the Union remains intact. While discussions and debates about secession may occur, they are unlikely to lead to any tangible results in the near future.