Why Tyrion Chose Bran Over Jon as King: A Deeper Analysis

When looking at the decision made by Tyrion Lannister to make Bran Stark the king, it's important to explore both the in-universe and real-world reasons behind his choice. This decision was made to ensure the stability and security of the realm, showcasing a strategic and pragmatic perspective.

In-UNiverse Explanation

The choice to have Bran as king is rooted in his unique abilities. In-universe, Bran Stark is known as the Three-Eyed Raven, a mystical entity who has the power to see into the past, present, and future. This gift is not just a simple prophecy but a powerful tool that allows him to foresee threats and anticipate problems before they occur. By making Bran king, Tyrion ensures that the kingdom will benefit from this prophetic foresight, allowing for more efficient problem-solving and long-term planning.

The Knowledge and Storytelling Aspect

Bran's knowledge is unparalleled in the realm of Westeros. He is the holder and keeper of all stories, capable of understanding the deep wisdom of the ancient times and applying it to modern challenges. This omniscient quality enables him to see through potential conspiracies and threats, securing his position and the stability of the kingdom. His ability to avoid repeating past mistakes, such as famines and wars, ensures that the realm benefits from a more reliable and secure rule.

The Real-World Reasoning

Beyond the in-universe explanations, the real reason for this choice emerges from the limitations of the source material. George R.R. Martin, the author, has not completed his series, leaving the showrunners to fill in the gaps with their own creative choices. The decision to make Bran king serves as a narrative device, providing a way to continue the story while avoiding the limitations of the incomplete books. This approach also aligns with the overall theme of the series, which often explores the idea of fate and the unpredictable nature of power.

Securing the Throne and Avoiding Dynastic Conflicts

Tyrion's choice of Bran reflects a deep understanding of human nature and the pitfalls of royal succession. He believes that giving someone the throne simply because their father was the king is a dangerous path. This perspective is exemplified by characters like Joffrey and Daenerys, who were raised with an innate sense of entitlement and often acted out of malice or a lust for power. Bran, on the other hand, lacks such ambitions. He views his role as a dispassionate and pragmatic king, without any desire to cause misery or engage in cruelty for personal amusement.

Moreover, Bran's abilities provide a unique solution to the issue of succession. His long lifespan and prophetic abilities ensure that he can rule indefinitely, addressing the constant squabbles and conflicts that arise from competing heirs. This stability is crucial for the realm, as it allows for a more peaceful and orderly transition of power.

Conclusion

In choosing Bran as king, Tyrion demonstrates a keen understanding of both the mystical and practical aspects of leadership. His decision is strategic and thoughtful, prioritizing stability, knowledge, and the best interests of the realm over personal or familial ambitions. This choice aligns with the themes of the series, emphasizing the importance of wisdom, foresight, and the pragmatic approach to governance.

Keywords: Tyrion Lannister, Bran Stark, Jon Snow, House Stark, A Song of Ice and Fire