Introduction

Since the late 1990s, the Stargate franchise has captivated audiences with its blend of science fiction, adventure, and character-driven storytelling. Among its many series, Stargate SG-1 stands out as a pioneer, setting a high bar for quality and consistency that subsequent shows have often tried to emulate. Let's explore why Stargate SG-1, and its sequels, particularly Atlantis, are so great.

Consistent and Well-Considered Characterization

The characters in Stargate SG-1 and its sequels are some of the most well-developed in television history. Unlike many shows where characters are rewritten every episode, these series maintain a basic structure that allows each character to have a clear identity. This foundational structure is ever-present, even as the characters evolve over time. For instance, Colonel Jack O'Neill, played by Richard Dean Anderson, is a complex character who evolves from a government operative to a more ethical and compassionate leader throughout the series.

Good Use of Continuity

One of the standout features of the Stargate universe is its excellent use of continuity. Mistakes and morally questionable decisions made by the characters often come back to haunt them, while their good deeds are rewarded in unexpected ways. For example, in Stargate SG-1, the decision to destroy Thor’s Hammer on Cimmeria had serious consequences for the team. Similarly, betrayals committed by characters such as “Fifth” (theAlteran) result in dire consequences for the protagonists. Conversely, the heroes’ good intentions often lead to unforeseen and positive outcomes, fostering a sense of cooperation and unpredictability in the series.

Minimal Continuity Errors

While the use of continuity adds depth to the series, the production team has also been careful to minimize continuity errors. These errors can break the immersion for the audience and negatively impact the viewing experience. By maintaining a high level of accuracy in character arcs and plotlines, the shows keep the continuity consistent and engaging for the viewers.

Effective Humor to Ease Tension

The ability to balance humor with tension is a crucial element in any successful television series. Stargate SG-1 exemplifies this perfectly, with characters like Jack O'Neill often stepping in to lighten the mood in tense situations. The humor in Stargate SG-1 is well-timed and organic, enhancing the emotional impact of both humorous and dramatic scenes. Moreover, the show is adept at knowing when not to be funny, striking a delicate balance that keeps the plot moving without detracting from the main narrative.

Not Taking Itself Too Seriously: Self-Parody and Cliche-Poking

Achieving a balance between seriousness and humor is challenging, but Stargate SG-1 excels in this. The show frequently pokes fun at its own clichés and tropes, acknowledging the wackiness of its plot. This self-awareness is a hallmark of the series, as characters are fully aware of how strange their daily lives are. This self-mocking approach makes the story even more engaging, as viewers can join in the fun while the characters are aware of the absurdity of their situations. Episodes like “Holiday” and “The Road Not Taken” are prime examples of this self-parody, where the universe humorously reimagines or satirizes its own tropes.

Comparison with Stargate Atlantis

While Stargate SG-1 is often regarded as the pinnacle of the franchise, Atlantis also offers its own merits. However, it is not without its flaws. Atlantis occasionally stoops to situations that are less credible, such as treating the episode “McKay and Mrs. Miller” as a joke, focusing on the hijacking of McKay’s body by female airmen. But these shortcomings are relatively minor compared to the strengths of the main series. Additionally, Atlantis frequently stoops to unethical behavior, such as experimental procedures on prisoners of war, which a character like General Hammond would not condone. While this adds complexity to the series, it sometimes detracts from the overall quality and coherence.

Conclusion

In conclusion, Stargate SG-1 and its sequels are immensely successful shows, particularly the original series. Their consistent and well-considered characterization, effective use of continuity, and balanced approach to humor contribute significantly to their enduring popularity. While Atlantis may not reach the same heights in some aspects, it still manages to offer engaging storytelling and memorable moments.