Why Some View the New Doctor Who Series as an Abysmal Failure

Imagine a scenario where fans and critics alike are divided over a new series of a beloved franchise. In this case, it's the Doctor Who series under the direction of Russell T Davies (RTD), featuring Nia Gatwa in a significant role. This article delves into why some viewers believe these new episodes to be a total failure, addressing multiple aspects of the issue from writing quality to fan reception.

Challenges with the New Cast and Fresh Perspective

RTD's return with Nia Gatwa has not been without controversy. Some critics express dissatisfaction, not purely because of Gatwa's race or sexuality, but due to perceived missteps in storytelling and character development. One of the main criticisms is that Gatwa’s character, Shitty Gatwa, seems to represent a deficiency in both acting and writing. As one individual stated, 'I can't stand Shitty Gatwa as a person, again not because he’s gay but because he shat on the fans.'

Disapproval of Character and Plot Decisions

RTD's character decisions in The Doctor series have faced scrutiny. A notable instance is Davros, a character meant to represent disability and evil. RTD, however, turned Davros into a middle-aged, healthy man in a plot twist that many found perplexing and contradictory.

The writing has also been criticized for feeling recycled, with storylines that only appeal to specific demographics. Prop designs and set pieces have been mockingly described as unimaginative, akin to the work of a "horny teenager with no imagination."

Promotion of Negativity and Anti-Fan Behavior

Beyond the writing and character decisions, some argue that the reliance on negative and dramatic storytelling has led to a deterioration in the series. Platforms like YouTube have enabled fans to monetize their content by sensationalizing and spreading hate, often at the expense of factual storytelling.

Some fans, driven by a thirst for negativity and clicks, spread disinformation and disingenuous views, turning into caricatures of themselves. These individuals profit from the drama, twisting the narrative and adding nonsensical lies just to garner attention and clicks. It is argued that this approach damages the quality of the show and alienates the loyal fanbase.

The Impact on Fan Perception

The impact on the fanbase is significant but often not reflective of the entire fan community. Critics often present these negative views as being widely shared, but the reality is that such opinions often come from a vocal minority, but remain influential.

While it's acknowledged that previous eras of Doctor Who had their flaws, the current focus on negativity and misinformation can sway those uninitiated or less engaged with the fandom. This can create a distorted perception that affects both new audiences and long-time fans.

Conclusion

The new Doctor Who series under RTD's direction, featuring Nia Gatwa, has certainly met with criticism from some fans. The writing, character development, and reliance on negative narratives are among the main points of contention. However, it is important to contextualize these views within the broader fan community and recognize the impact of negativity on the series and its perception.

Ultimately, it is up to the creators and producers to address these concerns and ensure that future episodes resonate more positively with a wider audience.