What Made 'Saw X' the Highest-Rated Saw Movie Ever?

While delving into the critical success of Saw X as the highest-rated entry in the Saw franchise on both Rotten Tomatoes and Metacritic, there is a fascinating narrative that unravels through its deliberate departure from the controversial Saw III. This article explores the reasons behind the film's critical acclaim, particularly focusing on its unique storyline, the iconic performance of Tobin Bell, and its appeal to longtime fans of the franchise.

The Impact of Saw III on the Franchise

One of the primary reasons for the critical acclaim of Saw X lies in its conscious decision to break away from the direction of Saw III. Saw III introduced Amanda Young, a character who abandoned the previous moral standards set by John Kramer (Jigsaw) and became a less relatable villain. This pivotal shift in the series' narrative direction marked a significant departure from the established storyline, leading to a series of creative missteps that the franchise would have to contend with in subsequent movies.

In Saw III, the protagonist Amanda Young's philosophy and actions took a dark and unpredictable turn, abandoning the very essence of Jigsaw's game. The film's conclusion saw both Jigsaw and Amanda being killed under ambiguous circumstances, marking a violent and abrupt end to their journey. The critical reception of this film was marked by a sense of dissatisfaction, as it seemed to abandon the core elements that made the original Saw and Saw II films so engaging and terrifying.

Understanding Saw III better, it is clear that the creators were setting a new narrative path that diverged significantly from the tried and true elements of the franchise. This decision, however well-intended, created a challenging narrative framework that would require subsequent films to address creatively. The death of these two protagonists, who were central to the franchise's success, created a void that was difficult to fill.

The Breakthrough with Saw X

Saw X is remarkable for its focus on a near-narrative-free zone. It shifts away from following the police or victims and instead centers around John Kramer and Amanda Young. By choosing to reboot the story, the filmmakers allowed the franchise to reestablish its foundations, essentially proving that a return to form could bring critical success.

Saw X successfully positioned itself as a modern reboot, offering a clean slate for the characters and narratives. It eliminated the complications introduced by Saw III, and instead focused on John Kramer and Amanda Young as powerful, unyielding antagonists. This approach resonated with audiences who were seeking a more straightforward and terrifying experience that harkened back to the roots of the franchise.

Tobin Bell’s Iconic Performance

A key factor in the critical acclaim of Saw X is the renowned performance of Tobin Bell as John Kramer (Jigsaw). Bell's portrayal of the signature character is a masterclass in bring a sinister and unsettling presence to the screen. His raspy voice and menacing gravitas are so compelling that they elevate even the most mundane scenes to the frenetic and terrifying levels that define the Saw franchise.

Bell's performance does not merely contribute to the film's success; it is a significant portion of its critical acclaim. Critics and audiences alike recognize his ability to deliver Jigsaw's chilling lines with such intensity that they become both memorable and threatening. His performance has earned critical praise and has helped solidify the legacy of the character.

Sustained Appeal to Longtime Fans

The critical success of Saw X also lies in its ability to appeal to a core fanbase that has grown up with the Saw franchise. Many fans of the original film and Saw II have a deep-rooted appreciation for the nuanced and psychological horror the franchise has provided. Saw X catered to this audience by returning to a version of the series that honors the elements that made the original so thrilling, while also offering a modern take on the franchise.

The film recognizes and celebrates the iconic status of both Jigsaw and Amanda Young, providing fans with a satisfying continuation that acknowledges and reinforces their importance to the series. This approach ensures that Saw X is not just a new beginning, but a respectful and thrilling conclusion to the narrative arc that has captivated fans over the years.