Why Robert De Niro Didn’t Play Don Corleone in a Fat Suit in 'The Godfather Part II' Final Scene

The Godfather Part II is a cinematic masterpiece that intertwines the past and present of the Corleone family, focusing primarily on Michael Corleone, played by Al Pacino. In this article, we will delve into the reasons behind the decision not to portray Don Corleone, as played by Robert De Niro, in his younger and fatter years through a fat suit in the final scenes of the film.

The Role of Robert De Niro and Marlon Brando

In the original Godfather, Marlon Brando played the iconic role of Don Vito Corleone, whereas Robert De Niro portrayed the younger version of Vito in The Godfather Part II. By the time of the sequel, the narrative shifts to focus on Michael Corleone and his struggle with the legacy of his father. Therefore, De Niro was not required to physically represent Don Corleone in the film.

The Narrative Structure and Storytelling Choices

The final scenes of The Godfather Part II emphasize the contrast between the past and present, highlighting the evolution and isolation of Michael Corleone. The story choices made by the writers, Puzo and Coppola, prioritize the emotional and thematic elements rather than a direct visual representation of the older Don Corleone. This decision allowed for a more profound exploration of the Corleone family dynamics and the legacy left by Don Vito.

The Downside and Limitations of Using a Fat Suit

Considering that Marlon Brando’s portrayal of Don Vito was so iconic, it would have been disconcerting if Robert De Niro was required to don a fat suit and reprise the role of Don Corleone. De Niro, who won the Academy Award for Best Supporting Actor for his portrayal of the young Vito, was already well-suited for the younger character. The use of a fat suit would have undermined this effectively and continuity-wise, it would have broken the link with the original film. The scene was very effective with Don Corleone off-screen, adding to the tension and emotional depth of the final moments.

The Meaning and Impact of the Final Scene

The final scene in The Godfather Part II avoids focusing on the physical presence of Don Vito, instead emphasizing the emotional dynamics between Michael and his siblings. This prequel scene reveals the characteristics of the characters we have seen develop in the two main films, highlighting the themes of family, legacy, and the unfolding of generational shifts. The scene underscores the timeless aspect of the Corleone family’s story by showing how their behaviors and dynamics remained consistent, even as the characters aged. The narrative choice reflects the universal truth that through the passage of time, the core essence of a person or family remains the same.

Conclusion

The decision not to have Robert De Niro portray Don Corleone in the fat suit for the final scenes of The Godfather Part II was a masterful choice that allowed for a more nuanced and emotionally resonant portrayal of the Corleone family’s legacy. The filmmakers wisely chose to focus on the dynamics between the characters rather than a direct visual representation of the older Don Corleone, resulting in a more impactful and memorable final scene.