Why People of Westeros Favored Renly Baratheon Over Stannis

The support for Renly Baratheon over his brother Stannis during the War of the Five Kings in A Song of Ice and Fire can be attributed to several key factors.

Charisma and Personality

Renly Baratheon was renowned for his charm, charisma, and remarkable ability to connect with people. He was often seen as a more approachable and likable figure compared to Stannis, who was frequently portrayed as stern, serious, and unyielding. Renly's natural charm and easy-going nature made him a favorite among both lords and commonfolk.

Youth and Vitality

Renly was younger and exuded a vibrant, energetic presence that appealed to many lords and common people alike. In contrast to Stannis#x27; more somber and brooding demeanor, Renly's youthful vitality made him a more appealing figure during the tumultuous period of civil war.

Military Reputation

Renly had a distinct reputation as a skilled knight and a capable leader. He had proven himself successful in tournaments and battles, which bolstered his image as a formidable candidate for the throne. His military prowess, combined with the backing of powerful allies such as the Tyrells of Highgarden, further strengthened his position.

Political Alliances

Renly secured the support of House Tyrell, one of the wealthiest and most influential houses in Westeros. The Tyrells provided him with substantial resources, troops, and legitimacy, making him a formidable contender for the Iron Throne.

Perception of Legitimacy

While Stannis was often viewed as the rightful heir to the Iron Throne, many saw Renly's claim as more appealing due to his lineage as the younger brother of King Robert Baratheon. Some supporters believed that a younger, more dynamic leader could better serve the realm. Renly's youth and charm made him a more relatable figure, adding to his appeal.

Stannis's Reputation

Stannis was often viewed as inflexible and ruthless. His strict adherence to the law and his willingness to execute perceived traitors alienated potential supporters. His alliance with Melisandre and the use of shadow assassins further caused unease among the nobility. Stannis' reputation as a cold and unyielding ruler made him less favored by many of the people in Westeros.

Symbolism and Pageantry

Renly embraced the symbolism of the Baratheon kingship, including the use of the stag sigil and the vibrant colors of his banners. This helped create a more appealing image of kingship that resonated with many. His use of symbols and pageantry further enhanced his charisma and made him a more attractive leader to the people of Westeros.

In summary, Renly's popularity stemmed from his charismatic personality, strong political alliances, military reputation, and the contrasting perception of Stannis's character and leadership style. This combination made him the favored choice among many lords and common people during the tumultuous period of civil war. Renly's ability to connect with people and his dynamic presence made him a compelling alternative to the more rigid and inflexible Stannis.