Why Negative Reactions to Scarlett Johansson in Ghost in the Shell Were Different from Positive Reception of Zendaya as Mary Jane

The reactions to Scarlett Johansson's casting in Ghost in the Shell and Zendaya's role as Mary Jane Watson in Spider-Man: Homecoming can be attributed to several nuanced factors including cultural representation, source material, and public perception.

Cultural Appropriation and Whitewashing Concerns (Scarlett Johansson in Ghost in the Shell)

Ghost in the Shell is based on a Japanese manga and anime that features a predominantly Japanese cast and setting. Many fans felt that casting a white actress in the lead role of Major Motoko Kusanagi was a form of cultural appropriation and overlooks the importance of representation for Asian characters in Hollywood. Such concerns have a long history in discussions about whitewashing.

Fan Expectations and Character Reinterpretation (Zendaya as Mary Jane Watson)

Zendaya's casting as Mary Jane Watson in Spider-Man: Homecoming was seen as a fresh take on the character. The filmmakers indicated that they were reimagining Mary Janes character which allowed for more flexibility regarding her ethnicity. This reinterpretation was welcomed by many fans as a move toward greater diversity in superhero films.

Support for Diversity and Cultural Relevance (Zendaya)

Zendaya is widely regarded as a talented actress and a positive role model. Her casting was celebrated by many as a step toward greater diversity in superhero films. The character of Mary Jane has been portrayed by different actresses in various adaptions, making her less tied to a specific racial identity in the eyes of some fans. This portrayal resonated with audiences who appreciate diverse representation in modern storytelling, especially in a franchise that aims to appeal to a broad audience.

Summary

In summary, the negative reaction to Scarlett Johansson's casting stemmed from concerns over cultural appropriation and representation, while Zendaya's casting was viewed more positively due to its alignment with contemporary values of diversity and reinterpretation.