Why Mormons Respond Differently to Trump Compared to Traditional Evangelicals

There's a nuanced discussion to be had about the differences in how Mormons, particularly those in Utah, respond to Donald Trump compared to traditional Evangelical Protestants. This response is more about the inherent characteristics of the Mormon community, rather than a logical reaction to Trump's policies or statements.

Hate and Otherness in Mormon Identity

Mormons in Utah are a close-knit community that values distinctiveness. They don't see themselves as merely a subset of the "everyman." Instead, they classify themselves as a religion-based ethic minority. This identity plays a significant role in their reactions to political figures like Donald Trump.

There's an instinctive and visceral reaction among Mormons to Trump, largely due to the fact that they view themselves as different from the broader American population. An article from Broadway that made fun of Mormons highlights their sense of otherness. Trump's dog whistles, or subtle coded messages, resonate less with Mormons, who might feel falsely accused or misunderstood.

Unpopularity and Dog Whistles

One of the reasons Mormons dislike Trump is the perception that he does not represent their values and dignity. Utah Mormons have long since formed a negative opinion of Trump, even earlier than some of their Republican counterparts. Mitt Romney, a prominent Mormon, did not lead this sentiment. The hatred towards Trump started during his campaign and has persisted beyond it.

Trump is not speaking to the Mormon community in Utah. Instead, he is more effective with a different demographic who is just realizing their own ethnic identity, as mentioned in a recent article. This group is waking up to their white identity and recognizing the need to assert themselves. However, this doesn't mean Utah Mormons logically reject Trump because of his comments on other ethnic groups. Anti-immigration and racist sentiments, though present, do not fully explain the divide.

Subtlety in Dog Whistles and Cultural Differences

Rhetorical devices like dog whistles can be easily misunderstood or missed by different cultural groups. While Republicans are consistently pro-Trump in Utah, those outside of Utah are more supportive. This highlights the importance of subtlety and the need for cultural sensitivity in political messaging.

The Mormon community in Utah also demonstrates a practical application of their values in everyday life. Unlike many Evangelicals, who might believe that their faith is primarily about Sunday worship and less about behavior, Mormons integrate their faith into their daily lives. This active practice of values makes them more likely to disassociate from a political figure they disapprove of.

Conclusion

The response of Mormons in Utah to Donald Trump is more than just a reaction to specific policies or statements. It reflects a broader identity and sense of otherness. While Utah Mormons share some political similarities with traditional Evangelicals, the distinctive values and community identity of the Mormon community lead to a different response to Trump.