Why Littlefinger Didn't Reveal Arya's Identity to Tywin Lannister

This analysis explores why Petyr Baelish (Littlefinger) might have failed to reveal Arya Stark's true identity to Tywin Lannister despite having the opportunity to do so. This question arises in the show adaptation of Game of Thrones, where the plot diverges somewhat from the books.

The Confusion and Opportunity

The simple and most plausible explanation is that Littlefinger didn't recognize Arya in the scene in question. The character's facial recognition was impaired by the fact that she had disguised herself effectively, much like the initial misidentification of Arya as a boy at King's Landing.

Furthermore, Tywin makes it clear to everyone present, including Raffetto (Raff Polliver), Pie (Hot Pie), and others, that Arya is indeed female. Littlefinger, being ever-watchful for an opportunity to advance his own interests, may have simply not taken this moment seriously.

Theoretical Benefits of Revealing the Truth

Littlefinger is known for his scheming and would have numerous potential uses for this information. He could have used it to leverage his position, making Sansa more subservient to him, or to climb the social ladder. He could also use this as leverage against Catelyn Stark or for personal gain.

Even if he chose not to reveal Arya's identity at that moment, he could still have hidden her to use as future leverage or as a bargaining chip. Considering his character, it would be illogical for him to miss out on such an opportunity.

The Motivations Behind Inaction

The true reason behind Littlefinger's inaction becomes clearer when examining his current position and goals in the story. At that point, he was still playing both sides, ingratiating himself with the Lannisters to maintain his position while simultaneously supporting Lysa Arryn and manipulating her into believing he was the one pulling the strings.

Additionally, Littlefinger still believed in his relationship with Catelyn Stark and eventually could see a way to be with her. He couldn't afford to betray her and put Arya in danger, as Arya was still Catelyn's daughter and a potential threat to his ambitions.

Theoretical Scenarios and Insights

Had Littlefinger known the situation was that critical, he might have had spies watch Arya or taken more drastic measures like kidnapping her, ensuring his own safety and ultimate advantage. The fact that he didn't is indicative of his broader strategic goals and the complexity of his character.

In conclusion, while the situation seems puzzling on the surface, a closer examination of Littlefinger's motives and the broader narrative makes his inaction more understandable. His refusal to reveal Arya's true identity aligns with his multifaceted and often contradictory character, highlighting the intricate nature of his role in the complex political landscape of Game of Thrones.