Why Is Wonder Woman 1984 Lacking in Logic? An Evaluation of Patty Jenkins' Directed Film

Introduction to Wonder Woman 1984

As the sequel to the critically acclaimed 2017 film Wonder Woman, directed by Patty Jenkins, the 2020 release of Wonder Woman 1984 was hotly anticipated. Despite its meticulous production design and impressive cast, the film garnered significant criticism for its numerous plot holes and logical inconsistencies. In this article, we will delve into why the movie Wonder Woman 1984 doesn't quite hold up to the standards set by its predecessor, particularly under the direction of Patty Jenkins.

Director's Background and Overall Vision

Lead by director Patty Jenkins, known for her work on films such as Suffragette and Bullet Train, Wonder Woman 1984 represents her second venture into the superhero genre. Jenkins has often emphasized the importance of authentic storytelling in her film choices and the role of women in leadership positions. Considering her previous experiences, it might be surprising that her directorial choices for this movie led to its logical shortcomings.

Plot Holes and Logical Gaps

Clarisse’s Knowledge and Memory Loss

One of the most glaring issues with Wonder Woman 1984 is the complex narrative involving Clarisse, Wonder Woman’s sister. Throughout the film, Clarisse suddenly possesses detailed knowledge about Wonder Woman’s past, which she could not have gained through normal means. The abrupt acquisition of this information creates a profound logical disconnect. Clarisse is a character who has essentially vanished from the story for years, and suddenly, she is eerily familiar with events that occurred without her.

Project Metallo and Stealth Technology

The film also struggles with several technical issues. For instance, Project Metallo, a character that appears as an ultra-high-tech warrior robot, should have been equipped with advanced stealth technology given the futuristic context. However, the robot’s visual design and behavior do not align with the expected capabilities of such a machine. A more believable and logically consistent approach would have been to showcase more advanced tactical maneuvers and less evident robotic abilities.

Anti-Venom’s Composition and Effectiveness

The portrayal of the anti-Venom in the film introduces a significant logical issue. Helena Wells explicitly mentions that the anti-Venom has a molecular structure similar to that of the serum that she created. However, the supposed effectiveness of this anti-Venom is never substantiated within the film, leaving viewers questioning the authenticity of this plot device. Given the importance of scientific accuracy in superhero films, the lack of a clear and coherent explanation for the anti-Venom’s composition and its actual effect creates a major obstacle to the suspension of disbelief.

Investigation of Patty Jenkins’ Role

Challenges of the Pre-Battle of Amazon Location

The battle between Wonder Woman and Maxwell Lord takes place in a deserted Greek island, an environment that poses significant challenges for the story’s logic. Notably, the island is described as being isolated and devoid of any local resources or inhabitants. Yet, the presence of Lord’s helicopter and the parties involved in transporting him raise questions about the island’s security and the logistics of such an isolated operation.

Believability of Public Outcry and Mainstream Media

The film’s depiction of the general public and mainstream media responses to the events of the story is another questionable aspect. Wonder Woman’s actions and their global impact are often exaggerated in a way that seems over-dramatic and disconnected from real-world public sentiment. The film’s portrayal of this media hype lacks consistency with the viewer’s understanding of how public opinion and media operate.

Conclusion and Final Thoughts

In conclusion, while the technical craftsmanship and performances in Wonder Woman 1984 are commendable, the film fails to maintain the high standards of logical continuity and internal consistency that set it apart from its predecessor. The directorial choices and narrative structuring not only detract from the overall quality of the film but also ultimately impact its credibility and appeal. As a sequel, the film struggles to meet the audience’s expectations and deliver a cohesive and believable storyline. Future entries in the DCEU would benefit from a stronger emphasis on storytelling and a more stringent commitment to logical consistency.

About the Author

Written by a seasoned film critic and journalist with over a decade of experience, this article offers a critical yet insightful look at the logical and narrative aspects of the film. With a focus on credibility and consistency, the analysis aims to provide a balanced and scholarly take on the issues raised.

Related Keywords

Wonder Woman 1984 Patty Jenkins movie logic superhero films film criticism