Why Independent Day: Resurgence's Alien Power Source Flaws Make No Sense

Introduction

In the movie Independence Day: Resurgence, the aliens' decision to tap into Earth's core for energy is perplexing. This choice seems arbitrary and lacks logical coherence. Critics argue that such alien behavior is fundamentally flawed, undermining the film's narrative and scientific plausibility.

Director Roland Emmerich, known for sacrificing scientific accuracy and plot consistency for explosive action, is often criticized for this approach in his films. However, even the most outrageous plot points are worth questioning, and the aliens' energy source is a prime example.

Alien Energy Source: Core vs. Sun

The aliens in Resurgence prefer to extract energy from Earth's core rather than harness the power of the Sun. This choice is puzzling. The Sun is a far more abundant and sustainable energy source, especially for an advanced alien civilization. Drilling into Earth's core is risky, destructive, and time-consuming. Why not simply use the Sun's boundless energy instead?

One possible explanation is that the aliens need a more contained and controlled source of power. Core-derived energy might be easier to manage and utilize in their technology. However, this theory still does not explain why they would choose such a difficult and dangerous method over a simpler alternative.

Roland Emmerich and Scientific Accuracy

Director Roland Emmerich has been notorious for prioritizing spectacle over scientific plausibility. His films often feature implausible plot devices and illogical actions by alien civilizations. In Independence Day: Resurgence, the aliens' behavior is just another example of this lack of coherence.

For instance, Roland Emmerich's films frequently rely on absurd plot points to advance the story, rather than logical reasoning. In Independence Day: Resurgence, the aliens' decision to extract core energy over a more sensible, time-tested energy source like the Sun seems to be a case in point.

Why Not a More Rational Approach?

It might seem that a more rational approach would be to exploit Earth's solar energy. However, the plot's need for entertainment and spectacle ensures that such rational choices are discarded. The aliens' actions are designed to create tension and excitement, not to make sense.

In the movies, the aliens serve as antagonists to be overcome by human heroes. As such, their actions are driven by the need to provide a thrilling and engaging story, rather than by logical necessity. This results in plenty of nonsensical plot points and choices that make no sense from a scientific or rational standpoint.

For example, the aliens' use of subterfuge and time to conduct their mission could have been more efficiently handled. Dropping asteroids or simply terraforming Mars or other planets would have offered a more practical and logical approach. The Sun's energy could have been harvested from a distance, making the mission more manageable and less dangerous.

Conclusion

The choice of using Earth's core as a power source in Independence Day: Resurgence is a glaring example of poor plot coherence and scientific logic. While Roland Emmerich's films are often criticized for sacrificing scientific accuracy, this decision stands out as particularly illogical. A more rational approach would have enhanced the film's credibility, making the story more compelling and believable.

Ultimately, the aliens' actions in the movie serve narrative purposes rather than scientific ones, relegating their behavior to the realm of the fantastical and unbelievable. This highlights the need for better plot coherence and scientific plausibility in science fiction films, ensuring that even the most outlandish concepts are grounded in logic.

Keywords: Independence Day: Resurgence, Alien Energy Source, Roland Emmerich, Movie Plot Coherence