Why I Avoid Reality TV and Why It’s Time to Say Goodbye

As a passionate consumer of TV programming, I find myself increasingly uncomfortable with the prevalence of reality shows in today's entertainment landscape. The decline in the quality of television programming, particularly with the rise of so-called 'reality' shows, has been a significant concern for me. My preference leans towards traditional drama and comedy, where narratives and performances are valued over contrived and superficial content.

My Issues with Reality TV

The notion that reality TV represents 'real life' is a colossal misnomer. In my opinion, these shows are dumbed down to the point of being almost unwatchable. Programs such as Love Island or The Only Way Is Essex (TOWIE) reduce complex human relationships and emotions into a series of clichéd interactions and trivial plot twists. Instead of showcasing genuine stories, these shows manufacture events to fit the narrative, skimping on authenticity and depth.

The majority of reality TV is not designed to provide insightful, meaningful content. Instead, the focus is on marketability, often prioritizing fame over quality.()1 Titles like 'Idol' may promise to discover the next musical sensation, but in practice, what is often revealed is a cash-grabbing exercise that prioritizes marketable personalities over true talent.

My Preference for Traditional Drama and Comedy

When it comes to entertainment, I find that traditional drama and comedy offer rich, nuanced narratives that resonate with me on a deeper level. These genres prioritize character development, compelling storytelling, and high-quality performances. A single line or a well-executed scene can transport me to another world, instilling a sense of empathy and understanding for the characters and their experiences.

Take, for example, Breaking Bad or The Crown. These productions captivate viewers with their intricate plotlines, complex character arcs, and historically accurate settings. The attention to detail in both writing and production is a testament to the value placed on crafting a genuine artistic experience for audiences. These shows are not just entertaining but also intellectually stimulating, offering a profound viewing experience.2

Comedies like The Office or Brooklyn Nine-Nine bring laughter to our lives, but they also explore relatable themes such as cultural diversity, work-life balance, and personal growth. They tackle issues with humor and grace, making them both entertaining and thought-provoking.

Reflections on the Changing Nature of Television

The shift in television from traditional programming to reality TV has been gradual but significant. It reflects a broader trend in society that favours spectacle over substance, and immediate gratification over meaningful content. While reality TV may provide temporary entertainment, it often leaves a hollow feeling upon reflection. The stories remain superficial, and the characters, while perhaps relatable, lack the complexity and authenticity that make traditional dramas and comedies so enduring.

It is important to recognize that while reality TV may be popular, it does not necessarily represent the best of what television can offer. As viewers, we have the power to demand better content. Promoting and supporting shows that prioritize storytelling and character development can help drive the industry towards a more meaningful and enriching form of entertainment.

Conclusion

My preference for traditional drama and comedy over reality TV is a reflection of my belief in the power of genuine storytelling. While reality shows may have their place in the entertainment market, they cannot replace the depth and complexity of narratives found in well-crafted TV productions. As an individual and as a culture, we should strive to support and consume content that elevates and enlightens us.

References

Reality TV is often criticized for its shallow and scripted nature, prioritizing marketability over true artistic value.^

Highly acclaimed dramas like Breaking Bad and The Crown have won numerous awards for their writing and production quality.^