Why Does the Blackfish Hatred for Jon Snow Run So Deep?

In the complex political landscape of Game of Thrones, the deep-seated resentment of the Blackfish (Brynden Tully) towards Jon Snow is a subject of much discussion. This hatred is rooted in a myriad of political, familial, and personal dynamics, deeply influenced by the decisions made following Robb Stark's death.

Political Dynamics and Succession

When Robb Stark named Jon Snow as his heir in the North, he made a significant political statement. Despite Jon's status as a bastard, this act acknowledged his importance and legitimacy. For the Blackfish, who was a loyal supporter of House Stark, this decision might have undermined the traditional line of succession and the Tully family's interests. This perceived challenge to the natural order of things could have fueled his resentment.

Loyalty and Honor

The Blackfish's character is marked by a strong sense of loyalty and honor. He has a particular attachment to his family and the Stark cause. His animosity towards Jon could stem from the perception that Jon's elevation as heir diminishes the claims of other Stark family members, particularly those from House Tully, which he represents. This sense of betrayal in the political landscape of the War of the Five Kings further exacerbates the Blackfish's frustration and hatred.

The Catelyn Factor

The Blackfish's niece, Catelyn, also harbors a deep mistrust of Jon Snow. This is not a personal vendetta but is rooted in broader familial issues. In the world of Westeros, there is a persistent and prevailing prejudice against bastard-born children. They are often viewed as 'born from lust and lies,' and are considered 'wanton and treacherous by nature.' This view is further cemented by the Blackfish's mistrust of Jon, particularly after the betrayal of Theon Greyjoy, who once served as Robb's ward.

Political Prejudice and Betrayal

The Blackfish suspects that the Lannisters schemed to position Jon Snow as Lord Commander of the Night's Watch in order to have him assassinated. This suspicion is reinforced by Theon Greyjoy's betrayal and the subsequent allegations of his involvement in the death of Robb Stark's children. The Blackfish appears to use Theon's actions to lend credence to his own mistrust of Jon, even though Jon was innocent.

Jane Galley, a trueborn son of Ned Stark, secretly scheme Samwell Tarly to get Jon elected as Lord Commander, believing he wouldn't be the best option. Samwell's efforts, while well-intentioned, might have been misinterpreted by the Blackfish as a political maneuver.

The Incessant Dispute

Catelyn's personal disdain for Jon Snow adds another layer to the narrative. Her husband, Ned Stark, brought Jon home as a child, despite having a legitimate child with Catelyn. This constant reminder of Ned's love for another woman, as well as the stigma of being a bastard, was a constant source of conflict. Additionally, Catelyn feared that Jon could pose a threat to her trueborn children's claims, a fear perpetuated by the prevailing prejudice in Westeros against bastards.

This uneasy alliance between Catelyn's hatred of Jon and the Blackfish's broader resentment creates a challenging and often antagonistic relationship. Despite never having met Jon, their shared mistrust and the broader political landscape of Westeros contribute to the deep-seated hatred each harbors towards the other.

Conclusion

The Blackfish's hatred for Jon Snow runs deep, rooted in a combination of political misunderstandings, personal betrayals, and the broader prejudices of Westeros. This complex interplay of emotions and politics makes for an intriguing narrative that adds depth to the characters of both the Blackfish and Jon Snow in the vivid world of Game of Thrones.