Why Does Star Trek: The Original Series Endure More Than The Next Generation?
Introduction
Star Trek, the beloved science fiction franchise, has captivated audiences for decades with its episodes across multiple series. While comparisons are often drawn between Star Trek: The Next Generation (TNG) and its predecessor, Star Trek: The Original Series (TOS), one cannot help but notice a fundamental difference: TOS endures more in the public consciousness. Despite TNG's longer run and deeper exploration of characters, TOS remains a cultural icon. Let's delve into why this is so.
Why Star Trek: The Original Series Endures More Than The Next Generation
Legacy and Cultural Impact
Compared to its direct spinoff TNG, which ran for 7 seasons, TOS managed only 3 seasons, yet its cultural impact remains profound. The enduring legacy of TOS can be seen in how it is generally remembered and referenced, while TNG is often overlooked. When someone mentions Star Trek, the common response is invariably TOS, not other series. This suggests a deeper and more widespread cultural acceptance of TOS.
Phrases and Concepts of Enduring Relevance
TOS has given us phrases and concepts that have transcended their original context and become part of everyday language. "Beam me up, Scotty," for example, is a phrase in common usage despite never having been used in TOS. Instead, it is a colloquial expression for calling someone to action or transportation, often used by people who have never watched the show. Another example is "warp speed," which has been adopted by Merriam-Webster as a term meaning "the highest speed possible" and has even been used by political figures in contexts unrelated to Star Trek.
"Vulcan" is another term that has taken on a life of its own. Originally a reference to Mr. Spock, it now describes a person who is perceived as overly analytical or unemotional. This term has become so prevalent that it is even used by members of Congress as a greeting, shifting away from traditional human gestures like handshakes.
Character and Iconic Status
Mr. Spock, the iconic science officer from TOS, has cemented his place in pop culture. Vulcans, with Spock as the original, have gained recognition and adoption in society. The phrase "Resistance is Futile" and the command "Make it so" from TNG, while popular, do not have the same enduring presence as those from TOS. These phrases have achieved a certain level of popularity, but they do not quite capture the same cultural impact as those originating from TOS.
For a lifelong Star Trek fan, this may go against my natural inclination to favor TNG. However, considering the broader cultural impact, TOS clearly has a more significant and enduring legacy.
Conclusion
While both Star Trek: The Original Series and The Next Generation have made significant contributions to the Star Trek universe, it is the Original Series that has left a more profound and lasting impression on popular culture. The phrases and concepts that originated in TOS have become integral to modern language, driving its enduring relevance. For those who love Star Trek, this question is not just about comparing the shows but understanding how they have shaped our world.
End Note:
As a lifer of Star Trek, I am all about TNG, and going against my grain, I must admit the strength of the enduring legacy of TOS. If anyone can provide evidence or insights to challenge this perspective, I am more than open to hearing your thoughts!