Why Does Sam Gerard Not Arrest Dr. Kimble in The Fugitive?

The Fugitive, a classic suspenseful thriller, has captivated audiences with its intricate storyline and compelling character development. One of the most intriguing plot points revolves around why Samuel Gerard, portrayed by Tommy Lee Jones, does not arrest Richard Kimble, played by Harrison Ford, even when it would be legally justifiable. This decision is pivotal in understanding the film's exploration of justice, integrity, and moral conduct.

Background and Context

The Fugitive is a captivating drama that revolves around Dr. Richard Kimble, a renowned cardiac surgeon who is framed for the murder of his wife. After being convicted despite his claims of innocence, Kimble goes on the run, turning his back on his past and life back home. Parallel to his journey is Samuel Gerard, a dedicated U.S. Marshal who is relentlessly pursuing him.

Gerard's Character Development and Motivation

Throughout the film, Gerard remains resolute in his pursuit of Kimble. However, as the narrative unfolds, he begins to develop a notion that perhaps Kimble is not guilty of the crime he was convicted of. This realization is a turning point in both their stories and forms the crux of the film's moral dilemma.

Gerard's transformation is one of the most critical elements of the plot. Initially, he is driven by the law and the need to fulfill his duty. However, as he delves deeper into Kimble's story, his allegiance to justice begins to outweigh his commitment to the letter of the law. This shift is highlighted in the climactic scene where Gerard listens to Kimble's confession and explanation for his actions.

The Climactic Scene and Its Impact

In the final confrontation, Kimble reveals the truth about his wife's murder and the identity of the real culprit. This act not only exonerates him but also ensures that the real villain is brought to justice. Instead of arresting Kimble and moving on, Gerard supports him in his pursuit of the truth. This decision underscores the complex ethical and moral choices he faces.

Gerard's choice to stand by Kimble's side emphasizes his commitment to doing what is right rather than strictly adhering to the legal framework. This moment of moral courage is a testament to the character's integrity and his belief in the power of truth and justice.

The Coexistence of Innocence and Guilt

While Kimble was framed for a crime he did not commit, his actions in the film are not entirely blameless. He escaped from prison and lived under false identities, which could be seen as breaking the law. However, these actions stem from a place of desperation and a quest for justice. He continued to live as a fugitive, but he also used his skills to save lives. In one scene, he performs a life-saving surgery on a critically ill man, demonstrating that he is far from the monster he was made out to be.

Themes of Justice and Morality in The Fugitive

The film deftly explores the themes of justice and morality through its portrayal of Kimble and Gerard. The central question posed by the film is whether Kimble's actions, though legally questionable, are morally justifiable. The resolution of the film, where Gerard acknowledges Kimble's innocence and allows him to continue his mission, speaks to a broader message about the complexities of justice and the moral obligations of law enforcement.

Conclusion

The Fugitive is a masterpiece that delves into the human condition, ethics, and the nature of justice. The decision of Samuel Gerard not to arrest Richard Kimble is a testament to the film's ability to blend suspense with deep moral inquiry. It challenges the audience to consider the nuances of justice and the importance of integrity.