Why Does Brienne of Tarth Not Seek Revenge Against Melisandre?

Much has been said about the intricate power dynamics and feuds in the grand world of Westeros. One compelling question that often arises is 'Why doesn’t Brienne of Tarth want or seek revenge against Melisandre for Renly Baratheon’s death?'
In the climax of the Game of Thrones series, the truth of Renly's death is unveiled, revealing a dark and complex story. According to the revelation, Melisandre was responsible for the shadow servant that carried out the murder, and it bore Stannis Baratheon’s face. However, for Brienne, the truth is clear, and justice is more nuanced.

Understanding the Truth Behind Renly's Death

Brienne, known for her unwavering justice and sense of honor, was acutely aware that the shadow servant carrying out the murder had Stannis Baratheon’s face painted on it. This revelation was significant because it implicated Stannis directly in Renly’s death. Although Melisandre had given Stannis the aid he needed to commit the act, the true executor of the deed was Stannis himself. Moreover, Melisandre had no personal connection to Renly, and seeking her revenge would not have truly addressed the source of Renly’s death.

Brienne's Reasoning: Personal vs. Institutional Justice

Justice in Westeros can be deeply personal. Brienne, who is driven by a sense of justice and the desire to clear Renly's name, would naturally seek vengeance against the person responsible for his death. However, she understands that Melisandre is not the one who executed the order. Instead, the true perpetrator is Stannis, whom Melisandre had aided by providing the means to kill Renly. This makes seeking revenge not only morally dubious but also strategically unwise.

Oversight of Authority Figures: A Lesson in Strategy

Brienne is a headstrong knight, known for her intelligence and strategic thinking. Even when she wanted to seek revenge, she recognized that Melisandre is a powerful sorceress. While Brienne is a formidable combatant, she is smart enough not to engage in a conflict that she is unlikely to win. This strategic thinking is a critical part of her character and ensures that she does not make rash decisions that could jeopardize her mission or personal safety.

Traditional Custom: Seeking the Right Adversary

It was a custom in Westeros to seek the one who gave the order, not the one who carried it out. This rule exemplifies a practical approach to justice and a recognition of the role of those who provide support and resources to commit crimes. According to this custom, Brienne would have logically focused her efforts on Stannis rather than Melisandre, understanding that only Stannis had the power and authority to issue such a deadly command.

Conclusion

Brienne’s decision not to seek revenge against Melisandre for Renly’s death is a testament to her honor and understanding of the complex nature of justice in Westeros. Her focus on the true culprit, Stannis, demonstrates her strategic thinking and her unwavering commitment to justice. This nuanced approach reflects her character and the sophisticated nature of the series.