Why Do Some Answer Writers Craft Such Lengthy Responses on QA Platforms?

Have you ever come across a situation where someone on a QA platform provides an impressively long and detailed answer to a seemingly simple query? This phenomenon is not unique to one platform or another; it is often observed on various QA sites and forums. Take, for example, the popular TV show Everybody Loves Raymond. In one episode, Deborah questions her husband Ray about his desire to write the great American novel, only to be met with a response that could last for ages. This comedic situation mirrors the experiences one can face when engaging with QA platforms today.

Highlights from TV and QA

In the episode of Everybody Loves Raymond mentioned, Deborah's question prompts a lengthy and somewhat impractical response from Ray. The scenario highlights a common occurrence in QA forums, where users can provide extensive and even overly long answers, often for questions that don't require such elaborate explanations. Similarly, on QA platforms, users like Rebecca (who has referenced a similar pattern in questions), often debate whether long answers are valued more highly than concise, to-the-point responses. This led to a discussion about the culture and norms of writing on these platforms.

Initial User Base and Culture

Initially, QA platforms such as Quora were frequented by a community of geeks and highly knowledgeable individuals. Due to invitation-only policies before it was linked with Facebook, these platforms catered to a niche audience of experts and enthusiasts who were passionate about sharing their thoughts and knowledge. This culture often incentivized writing detailed and thought-provoking answers because it was a way to demonstrate one's expertise. Early Quora users, for instance, were often academics, tech professionals, and other knowledgeable individuals who would take pride in crafting expansive, well-researched answers.

Expansion and Standardization of Answer Length

With the introduction of Facebook integration, Quora and other QA platforms began to grow rapidly. As a result, the user base expanded to include a broader spectrum of individuals, from common users to those who were less inclined towards intellectual discussions. This diversification also led to the expectation of longer, more detailed answers becoming the norm rather than the exception. Despite the influx of new users, the habit of providing thorough answers continued, often to the point where even trivial questions would receive detailed responses. This shift suggests that the community's norms and expectations evolved over time, driven by both platform growth and user behavior.

Encouraging Comprehensive Answers

While some might see lengthy answers as unnecessary, others argue that they are beneficial because they foster a deeper understanding of the topic at hand. Rebecca, in the discussion, touched upon her preference for structured and organized answers, much like a structured argument. In the realm of QA, providing a detailed, argumentative response can help users develop their knowledge in a more nuanced and comprehensive manner. These thorough answers can serve as valuable resources for other users, guiding them through the intricacies of a topic in a logical and easy-to-follow manner.

Concluding Thoughts

While the trend of crafting lengthy answers on QA platforms might seem overwhelming, it reflects the diversity and complexity of the user base. These answers serve as a testament to the dedication and expertise of those who take the time to provide detailed insights. Whether you prefer concise responses or enjoy the depth of a well-researched answer, understanding the origin and evolution of this phenomenon can offer insights into the nature of online discourse and knowledge sharing.

Keywords: