Why Do American TV Series Praise Police So Much?

The portrayal of police in American TV series has undergone a nuanced transformation over the years. While early shows often featured police as unassailably good, the 1980s brought some changes. Today, modern TV series often explore the complexities of law enforcement, including the presence of corrupt officers and the impact of policies on minority communities. This article will delve into the reasons behind the enduring popularity of positive police depictions in American TV series.

The Perceptions Behind Police Praise

People generally seek heroes, and in the context of American society, police officers often fill this role. A significant majority of Americans support law enforcement, and this is reflected in the popularity of police shows. This fervent support has roots in the work of influential figures like Jack Webb, who helped the LAPD gain public acceptance through his show Dragnet. However, there have been shifts in perceptions, as seen in the critically acclaimed Hill Street Blues of the 1980s, which began to highlight the flaws within police departments.

The Appeal of Crime Shows

Crime investigations are an ideal subject for serialization in TV due to their episodic nature. These shows don't require a lot of recurring cast and offer ample opportunities for guest stars, making them attractive for syndication. Additionally, the structure of case-per-episode procedural format is easy to maintain and satisfying for viewers. While it might seem like a simple admiration for cops, it's more about how the characters in these professions serve the narrative needs of television scheduling.

The Fundamentals of Policing in TV

A core aspect of American TV success is the clear contrasts between law enforcement and criminal elements. The formula cops are good, and criminals are bad satisfies a universal human desire to see justice prevail. Even vigilante characters like Dirty Harry provide catharsis, as their actions often serve as a form of justice denied by the system. While there is a general preference for good cops and disdain for the bad, this dynamic enriches character development and plot complexity.

The Impact on Real-World Perceptions

While TV shows are fictional, they do influence public perception. Police officers are often seen as the primary defense against criminals, and this is a key aspect of their public image. However, the portrayal of officers as overly heroic can sometimes create a gap between idealized police characters and the realities experienced by actual law enforcement. The historical treatment of certain minority groups by the police has led to deep-seated distrust.

The Motivations Behind Praise for Police

TV shows generally praise police officers for various reasons. Firstly, police characters represent the virtuous 'good guys' who stand for law and order. Secondly, non-criminals frequently appreciate these officers, and this appreciation translates into ratings. Lastly, these shows are popular and generate significant revenue, which is the most tangible motivator for producers.

It's worth noting that despite the popular depictions of police as heroes, many TV series also tackle the dark side of law enforcement. Shows like The Shield and Watchmen portray characters with questionable morals and practices. Even shows like Chicago P.D., known for its strong law enforcement focus, have characters with questionable actions.

The Intricacies of Crime Shows

While police drama is a significant portion of the genre, there are other elements that also draw viewers. The procedural aspects of crime shows, as seen in shows like Law Order, have a long-standing appeal. The intrigue of forensic science, rooted in the work of legendary detective Sherlock Holmes, has captivated audiences for years. However, the core elements of crime shows—whether it's the procedural aspects or the underlying narrative of wrongdoing—tapped into a hardwired human fascination with the forbidden and the rebellious.

Ultimately, the enduring popularity of positive police depictions in American TV series is a combination of cultural support, narrative convenience, and commercial success. While real-world complexities often cloud these portrayals, the enduring popularity of these shows attests to the enduring human desire for justice and heroes.