Why Didn't Stannis Baratheon Kill Melisandre in Game of Thrones S5E10?

In Game of Thrones Season 5 Episode 10, viewers are left wondering about the fate of Melisandre and her continued presence in the story. Despite her powerful abilities and the fact that she has left Stannis, why did he not choose to end her life? This article explores the reasoning behind Stannis's decision and the unique dynamics at play between these two characters.

Understanding the Power of Red Witches

Red witches, like Melisandre, are not just figures steeped in mythology. They possess abilities that extend beyond the realm of ordinary human knowledge. Their expertise in rituals, spells, and divinations often involves complex and dangerous practices, few of which are fully understood by those around them.

One of the most notable aspects of Melisandre's character is her immunity to certain forms of harm. In one of her POV chapters, she mentions that whenever she gazes into her night fire, her first concern is for her own safety. This suggests a powerful, protective force at work, likely a part of her unique connection to the Lord of Light.

Maeser Cressen's Attempt to Poison Melisandre

Maester Cressen's failed attempt to poison Melisandre provides a significant backstory to her near-invincibility. Cressen, in an act of desperation to save Stannis, brewed a potent poison and offered it to Melisandre. Despite the poison's lethality, Melisandre was protected by her inherent powers, surviving the encounter unharmed. This event demonstrates the extent of Melisandre's immunity and the potential consequences of underestimating her abilities.

The Timing and Stannis's Priorities

Stannis's decision not to kill Melisandre is deeply tied to the urgency of his situation. When Stannis walked in on his wife’s dead body, he was faced with a critical moment. At that point, his primary concern was the swift and decisive march to Winterfell. Melisandre's desertion, while a significant blow, was not enough to derail his immediate goals.

Stannis was acutely aware of the perilous state of his army, diminished by battles and the harsh winter they faced. His family's complete loss meant that his own life became even more critical for the Baratheon claim to the Iron Throne. This made his decisions more cautious, especially when dealing with a figure as powerful as Melisandre.

The Dangers of Melisandre's Powers

Beyond Melisandre's immunity to certain forms of harm, Stannis is also wary of the dark powers she wields. He is well aware of the evil that she brought into the world, which led to Renly's death. The realization that she has the potential to replicate such actions presented a significant threat. Even though he may have wanted to kill her, the urgency of his mission and the fear of her power kept him from acting rashly.

The Strategic Decision

Ultimately, Stannis chose to forgo the immediate act of killing Melisandre because he knew that simply removing her was not enough. He understood that her powers, while dangerous, were also a potential tool that could be used to further his own ends. By treating her with a degree of caution and allowing her to leave, he ensured that she could not be used against him in a way more damaging than her departure.

Conclusion

The decision to not kill Melisandre in S5E10 of Game of Thrones is a complex one rooted in Stannis's strategic thinking and the unique dynamics of their relationship. While her immunity to poison is a significant factor, Stannis's need to secure his claim to the Iron Throne and the lingering danger posed by her powers played a crucial role in his actions.

Ultimately, this decision sets the stage for future conflicts, showcasing the intricate web of power and intrigue that drives the narrative of Westeros.