Why Didn't Missandei Push Cersei Off the Parapet?

In the tense and dramatic scene from Game of Thrones where Missandei and Cersei stand at the parapet, Missandei's inaction has sparked considerable debate. Why didn't she take the opportunity to act against Cersei, potentially saving thousands of lives and becoming a hero in the process? This article delves into the multifaceted reasons behind Missandei's decision, exploring power dynamics, emotions, and narrative purpose.

Power Dynamics

The scene between Missandei and Cersei is characterized by a significant power imbalance. Cersei, as the antagonist, holds Missandei captive and uses her as leverage against Daenerys. This power dynamic means that any act of rebellion by Missandei would likely result in immediate and fatal consequences. Cersei's guards and the overall context of the scene underscore the fact that Missandei's survival was not a viable option. Such a scenario reflects the harsh realities of power and control, where a weaker individual's actions can easily be quashed.

Desperation and Fear

Missandei's position at the parapet is not just about negotiating a compromise; it is also a place of vulnerability and fear. She is surrounded by Cersei's guards, and any move that might be perceived as a threat could result in swift and severe retaliation. In such a high-stakes moment, the likelihood of Missandei surviving an act of defiance is slim. Her safety would be at a greater risk, and the outcome would be dire.

Emotional Stakes

Missandei's character is portrayed as loyal and composed, even in dire situations. Instead of acting out of immediate anger or desperation, Missandei's focus is on sending a powerful message to Daenerys. Her actions are not driven by a desire for personal vengeance but by a strategic communication to her queen. This suggests that Missandei's decision is rooted in a deeper, emotional understanding of the situation and the impact it could have on the ongoing conflict.

Narrative Purpose

From a storytelling perspective, Missandei’s fate serves to heighten the tension between Daenerys and Cersei. Her inaction is a crucial part of the narrative, pushing the plot forward and emphasizing the stakes of the conflict. By not pushing Cersei off the parapet, the scene becomes a symbolic act of loyalty and strategic communication, rather than a moment of impulsive reaction.

This combination of power imbalance, fear, emotional loyalty, and narrative necessity contributes to Missandei's decision not to act against Cersei in that moment. Her inaction is a reflection of the complex tension between survival, loyalty, and the larger narrative structure of the show. While it might have offered a dramatic and heroic ending, the show’s writers chose to prioritize character development and the overarching narrative arc over an immediate, one-dimensional resolution.

The Missed Opportunity and its Consequences

Many argue that Missandei's inaction was a missed opportunity, as it could have saved lives and turned her into a hero. However, the reality is that Missandei had little to gain and much to lose by making such a move. Her immediate survival was not a possibility, and her role in the scene was to send a message of loyalty and strategic communication rather than personal revenge.

Even if Missandei had attempted to push Cersei, the outcome was never guaranteed. Cersei's guards would have likely intervened, making the scenario more complex and less dramatic than a solitary kung fu battle. Furthermore, Missandei's role in the larger narrative goes beyond a simple act of self-defense. Her character serves to highlight the complexity of the conflict and the thin line between survival and sacrifice.

The Moral Implications

The question of Missandei's gentle nature and whether she was capable of "murdering" someone is often discussed. While it is important to consider the ethical implications of any character's actions, Missandei's last moments were about survival and loyalty. Instructing Daenerys to perform a dragon fire attack on King's Landing, while controversial, is a strategic move within the context of the story.

G.R.R. Martin's writing style often includes unexpected plot twists and the downfall of powerful characters due to their own flaws. Missandei's decision not to act against Cersei can be seen as an integral part of this broader narrative, where even a seemingly meek character can have a significant impact on the course of history.

Conclusion

Ultimately, Missandei's decision not to push Cersei off the parapet is a complex interplay of power dynamics, fear, loyalty, and narrative necessity. While it might have offered a more dramatic and heroic ending, the show's writers chose to prioritize character development and the larger narrative arc. Missandei's inaction is a reflection of the complex tension between survival, loyalty, and the overarching narrative of Game of Thrones.