Why Didn't Michael Kill Kay in The Godfather Part 2?

The reasoning behind Michael Corleone not killing his wife, Kay Adams, in The Godfather Part II is multifaceted. Michael, despite his reputation for cold-bloodedness, is not a psychotic individual. The decision to not harm Kay is primarily rooted in the emotional complexity of their relationship and the cultural and personal values that shape his character.

Emotional Depth of Michael and Kay's Relationship

While Kay didn't participate in Mafia activities, her significant contribution to Michael's life as a wife and mother makes her an integral part of his personal identity. This is further reinforced by the fact that Michael harbored deep love for Kay throughout his life. Even during his marriage to Apollonia, a love that some might find offensive to mention, Michael's enduring affection for Kay remained steadfast. Michael's anger upon learning about her abortion was tempered by his love, leading him to cruelly shut the door on her—a move that can only be understood through the lens of profound love and respect.

Michael's Traditions and Ethics

Michael is a man who believes in traditional values and ethical codes. He adheres to the notion that harming a woman, especially the mother of his children, is not something his culture deems acceptable. This belief stems from his strong respect and love for his own mother. Kay, as the mother of Anthony and Mary, became a symbol of the sanctity of familial ties within Michael's worldview. The inviolability of motherhood made it unthinkable for Michael to harm her. This ethical stance is also reflected in his decision to wait for their mother's death before removing Fredo from their lives, thereby ensuring she wouldn’t witness such a terrible act.

Michael's Family Loyalty and His Attempts for Legitimacy

Furthermore, Michael's inaction towards Kay is a testament to his loyalty to his family, including his children. Although he was involved in the Mafia and trying to make things legitimate within his family, his maternal duties and his wife Kay's anti-Mafia stance played a critical role in shaping his choices. Kay was not only his wife but also an advocate for her family's traditional lifestyle. Her actions, such as aborting the child, were a direct violation of the traditional values Michael was trying to uphold. Despite the frustration caused by her actions, he would never jeopardize the lives of Anthony and Mary by harming their mother.

Conclusion

In sum, Michael's decision not to harm Kay represents a complex interplay of emotions, cultural values, and ethical principles. His love for Kay, respect for his mother, and loyalty to his children all contributed to this decision. The Godfather's portrayal of Michael as a man with a soul, even within the shadowy world of organized crime, adds depth and nuance to his character.