Why Did the Umbers Loyal to the Boltons Over the Starks? A Study in Game of Thrones Loyalties

Introduction

In the Game of Thrones TV show, the Umbers' allegiance to the Boltons in the tumultuous aftermath of the War of the Five Kings is a fascinating and complex storyline. This piece delves into the reasons behind their loyalty, exploring historical context, political expediency, fear and coercion, personal ambition, and distrust of the Starks.

Historical Context

The political landscape of Westeros has always been marked by shifting allegiances and constant warfare. The Umbers, like many other families in the North, have long been embroiled in the longstanding rivalry with the Starks. However, the events of the War of the Five Kings marked a significant turning point. With the deaths of many members of the Stark family, traditional alliances began to crumble, and power vacuums emerged that new factions sought to fill.

Political Expediency

Under such chaotic and unforgiving circumstances, political expediency often dictates policies and alliances. By supporting the Boltons, House Umber could have hoped to gain favor and protection in a world where the balance of power was in flux. The Boltons, having secured power in Winterfell, were in a position of strength, and aligning with them would have offered a safer and more stable future for House Umber.

Fear and Coercion

The Boltons were known for their brutal and uncompromising nature. They may have used intimidation and the threat of violence to secure the loyalty of other families. Fear of reprisal or violence from the Boltons, or from the deteriorating situation if they remained neutral, would have been compelling reasons for House Umber to defect to the side of power.

Personal Ambition

Individual members of House Umber might have had personal ambitions that aligned more closely with the Boltons. By supporting the ruling house, they could position themselves for advancement and greater influence, contributing to their own power and status. The Umbers, like many families in Westeros, are complex and driven, with personal ambitions often clashing with familial and traditional loyalties.

Distrust of the Starks

Following the fall of the Stark family and the subsequent chaos, some families in the North may have viewed the Starks as weakened and unable to protect them. The Starks had been the traditional rulers of the North, and their perceived incapacity to fulfill this role could have led to a shift in loyalty. The Umbers, among many others, might have felt that the Boltons provided a safer and more reliable choice.

Analysis of the Northern Lords' Loyalties

After Season 3, the Northern lords appeared to prioritize their own interests over their traditional oaths to the Starks. Timon of the Blind Flint and Unwin Fell Glover are notable examples, demonstrating a willingness to betray their own houses and even their lady for personal gain or to align with the powerful and ruthless. Glover, in particular, is a case study in treachery, twice running away from fights and urging Sansa to remove Jon from the line of succession.

The loyalty of the Boltons' supporters, including the Umbers, highlights the themes of survival and power in Game of Thrones. Loyalty was often fleeting and contingent on power and protection, rather than traditional bonds or historical feuds. The memory of kindness and favors was often overshadowed by the prospect of immediate survival and power.

Conclusion

The Umbers' decision to align with the Boltons over the Starks is a reflection of the complex political dynamics and harsh realities in Westeros. It underscores the fluid nature of alliances in a world where power is often obtained through violence and negotiation. The Northern lords, with their various motivations, serve as a microcosm of the larger narrative, showing how personal gain and survival can often trump traditional loyalties in times of crisis.