Why Did the Joker Movie Get Such a Low Score on Rotten Tomatoes?

The highly anticipated 2019 film Joker, directed by Todd Phillips and starring Joaquin Phoenix, received a mixed response from critics, with mixed reviews contributing to its score on Rotten Tomatoes. This article will explore the reasons behind the movie's lower score, as well as its commercial success and audience reception.

Controversial Themes

One of the main reasons for the film's low score on Rotten Tomatoes was the controversial portrayal of mental illness and violence. The movie delves into complex themes such as mental breakdowns and societal neglect, which sparked significant debate. Yet, critics were divided on whether the film handled these issues respectfully or irresponsibly.

Characterization and Tone

Several reviewers felt that Joker glorified the Joker's descent into madness and violence, potentially sending problematic messages about anti-heroes and neglect. However, Joaquin Phoenix's standout performance received widespread praise, even if some critics found issues with the film's pacing and narrative structure.

Expectations vs. Reality

Another factor contributing to the mixed reviews was the high expectations surrounding the film itself. Given the movie's high-profile backing and the legacy of the character, audiences and critics had high hopes for the film's execution. However, many felt that the film did not live up to the potential of its concept, leading to a critical divide.

Commercial and Critical Success

Despite the mixed critical reception, Joker was a commercial success, winning several awards and securing Joaquin Phoenix's Best Actor Academy Award. The audience score on Rotten Tomatoes was notably higher than the critics score, highlighting a divide between critical and popular reception.

Mixed Reactions From the Audience

Some viewers defended the film, believing that Joker was misunderstood or that it had a significant impact on how the character is perceived. For example, one innocent viewer commented: 'Because people who watched it are underage children who don’t understand mental health, it’s a great movie and I honestly recommend.' Another viewer stated: 'I guess [Joker is] overrated because once the dust settled and people got comfortable with the fact that it is possible for an actor’s work to transcend the vehicle of that work... they realize “Hey! That movie sorta sucks.”'

Analysis of Criticisms

Some of the most common criticisms revolved around the film's direction and storytelling. While many praised the editing and music, others felt that the story was a poor retread of much better works. Critics often pointed out the inconsistencies in the plot, such as the Joker's supposed descent into madness, his actions, and his interactions with other characters.

Concluding Thoughts

The mixed reviews of Joker on Rotten Tomatoes reflect a complex interplay of thematic controversy, mixed character portrayals, and divergent audience expectations. Despite these challenges, the film's impact and significance cannot be denied, as evidenced by its critical and commercial successes.