Why Did Robb Stark Not Ally with Stannis Baratheon After Failing with Renly?

After Robb Stark's failed alliance with Renly Baratheon, one might wonder why he did not consider an alliance with Stannis Baratheon. Robb's decisions were driven by a combination of strategic, political, and personal reasons. Let's delve deeper into these factors and explore why he ultimately did not pursue an alliance with Stannis.

Stannis's Claim to the Throne

Stannis Baratheon's claim to the Iron Throne was a key factor in Robb's decision. Robb was primarily focused on asserting his independence and securing the North. An alliance with Stannis could have introduced unnecessary complications, as it might have undermined Robb's own goals and created divisions among potential allies. In the complex political landscape of Westeros, an alliance with Stannis could have jeopardized his strategic positioning.

Stannis's Reputation

Stannis Baratheon was known for his uncompromising nature and his unwavering belief in law and justice, which often transcended political maneuvering. This rigid approach might have made Robb wary, as it could have clashed with the flexible political strategies that he needed to navigate the volatile Westerosi environment. Robb's tactical alignment with more pragmatic leaders who could offer strategic support might have been more beneficial for his cause.

Focus on the North

Following Renly's death, Robb Stark's primary focus was on consolidating his power in the North and addressing the immediate threats posed by the Lannisters. His military campaigns were crucial for his survival and his ability to continue the war against the Lannisters. Engaging in a broader political struggle for the Iron Throne was not a top priority for Robb, as he had more immediate concerns to address.

Lack of Immediate Benefit

Furthermore, an alliance with Stannis might not have provided Robb with immediate military or political advantages. At the time, Stannis was already engaged in his own battles against the Lannisters and might not have had the resources or means to offer substantial support to Robb. This lack of immediate benefit made it less likely for Robb to pursue an alliance with Stannis.

Stannis's Actions Against the Lannisters

Stannis was more focused on his own war against the Lannisters and did not have a particular interest in the Northern conflict. While Robb might have seen Stannis as a potential ally, he recognized that Stannis's priorities lay elsewhere. This strategic dissonance made an alliance with Stannis less appealing for Robb, as it would not have provided the necessary support for his immediate goals.

In conclusion, Robb Stark's decisions not to ally with Stannis Baratheon after his failed alliance with Renly were multifaceted and were driven by strategic, political, and personal considerations. By focusing on consolidating his power in the North and addressing the immediate threats posed by the Lannisters, Robb made choices that best served his needs in the complex political landscape of Westeros.