Why Did People Hated Ginny Because She Hates Fleur While Hermione Didn’t Encounter the Same Criticism?

In the vast world of J.K. Rowling's Harry Potter series, characters such as Hermione Granger and Ginny Weasley share a common dislike for Fleur Delacour, the charming and elegant Beater. However, their reactions towards Fleur are often viewed differently, with Hermione's disdain being less scrutinized compared to Ginny's. This article delves into the reasons behind this difference in perception and the underlying factors that contribute to the contrasting judgments of these two characters.

Character Development

Ginny's Role and Exposure: In the later books of the Harry Potter series, Ginny Weasley's role becomes more prominent. Her feelings and opinions about characters like Fleur Delacour are more visible and accessible to the readers. This greater exposure of Ginny's disdain for Fleur makes it more noticeable and subject to scrutiny. On the other hand, Hermione's expressions of disapproval are often context-specific and may be less clear to the reader, thus receiving less attention.

Jealousy and Rivalry

Ginny's Jealousy: Many readers interpret Ginny's dislike of Fleur as stemming from jealousy, particularly because Fleur is engaged to Bill Weasley, Ginny's brother. This personal connection may intensify the perceived pettiness and lack of reason in Ginny's feelings. The intimate familial bond between Bill and Fleur adds a layer of complexity to the situation, making Ginny's actions seem more inappropriate to the readers.

Hermione's Detachment: While Hermione also expresses disapproval of Fleur, her critiques are often framed within a more analytical and less emotional context. Hermione's behavior can be seen as more justifiable because she is addressing Fleur's actions rather than personal feelings. Fleur's behavior, especially during the Triwizard Tournament, provides a clear and logical basis for Hermione's disapproval. This more detached approach contrasts with Ginny's brash and seemingly unfair reaction to Fleur.

Reader Sympathy and Perception

Reader Sympathy for Hermione: In comparison to Ginny, readers often sympathize more with Hermione due to her established character traits of intelligence and loyalty. Hermione's actions are generally seen as more measured and justified. However, Ginny's development throughout the series is still in progress, and her actions are sometimes perceived as brash or unfair. As a result, the criticism of Ginny's behavior is often more severe and direct than that of Hermione.

Examples and Comparison: When examining specific instances, Hermione’s critique of Fleur is grounded in Fleur's actions during the Triwizard Tournament. Hermione's earlier relationship with Fleur, particularly her participation in the tournament, provides a solid foundation for her disapproval. In contrast, Ginny's disdain for Fleur is often due to her personal dislike of Fleur, which is evident in the nickname “Phlegm” and her bullying behavior, leading to a more negative portrayal in the readers' eyes.

Conclusion: The contrasting reactions to Hermione and Ginny's dislike for Fleur are influenced by character development, emotional context, and reader perception. While both express negative feelings, the nuances in their reactions and the surrounding circumstances create different impressions. Hermione's disapproval is often more justifiable and less personally driven, while Ginny's feelings are perceived as more brash and unfair.

Having said that, it's important to note that while I understand and can relate to Hermione's behavior to some extent, I personally do not approve of her treatment of Fleur. While it could be seen as motivated by jealousy, Hermione's critiques are less brutal and offensive than Ginny's. Moreover, my own feelings towards Fleur are not particularly positive, so my perception of her might be biased.

In summary, the differences in how listeners perceive the negative feelings of Hermione and Ginny towards Fleur can be attributed to the depth of their characters, the context of their criticisms, and the sympathy readers feel for each.