Why Did Howland Reed Keep Jon Snow's Identity Hidden?

The decision of Howland Reed, the last living member of House Reed, to keep Jon Snow's true identity secret for so long is a pivotal element in the political and narrative complexities of A Song of Ice and Fire. This article explores the multifaceted reasons behind his actions, examining the key themes of protection, loyalty, and timing in the series.

Protection of Jon Snow

Howland Reed, as the last remaining member of House Reed, had a strategic reason to protect Jon Snow. Revealing Jon's true parentage as the son of Lyanna Stark and Rhaegar Targaryen could have placed him in considerable danger, especially given the political tensions surrounding the Targaryens and the Starks. By concealing Jon's identity, Reed aimed to safeguard him from potential adversaries and ensure his survival in the tumultuous world of Westeros.

The Stark Legacy

Howland Reed's alliance with House Stark further motivated his decision to keep Jon's identity secret. By maintaining this ambiguity, he was able to protect the Stark legacy and its influence over Westeros. Revealing that Jon was a Targaryen would have added an unprecedented layer of complexity to the already contentious dynamics of the war for the Iron Throne. This revelation could have undermined the Stark children's claims to power and stabilized the precarious balance of political interests.

Knowledge of Bran's Journey

Howland Reed was well aware of Bran Stark's journey and his role as the Three-Eyed Raven. Despite his understanding of Bran's importance, Reed likely believed that revealing Jon's identity could disrupt the delicate balance of power and trust that was forming. His knowledge of Bran's fate suggested that Jon's true heritage was not yet the time for revelation, as it could interfere with the critical role Bran was destined to play.

The Importance of Timing

The strategic timing of revealing Jon's identity is crucial in the narrative of A Song of Ice and Fire. Howland Reed may have believed that the right moment for this revelation had not yet arrived, and that Jon should navigate his path to adulthood without the burden of his heritage. This approach allowed Reed to manage the political situation more effectively, ensuring that Jon could establish a foundation for his future role in the conflict.

Personal Discretion and Cautious Nature

Howland Reed is known for his cautious and wise nature, often making rational and calculated decisions. His decision to keep Jon's identity hidden aligns with his character traits and the broader themes of secrecy and trust in the series. His discretion can be seen as a form of wisdom, ensuring that important revelations are made at the right time and in the right context.

Conclusion

In summary, Howland Reed's choice to keep Jon Snow's identity hidden was a combination of protective instincts, loyalty to House Stark, and a strategic decision based on the volatile political landscape of Westeros. Reed's actions reflect the complexity of the series, highlighting the importance of trust, timing, and loyalty in a world where secrets and revelations can shape the course of history.