Why Did Clark Gable Initially Decline the Role of Rhett Butler in Gone with the Wind?

Clark Gable, the legendary actor known for his charismatic performances, initially turned down one of his most iconic roles in the film history – that of Rhett Butler in Gone with the Wind. This decision, though brief, is deeply rooted in multiple factors.

Typecasting Concerns

One of the primary reasons Gable declined the role was his fear of being typecast in romantic leading roles. Gable, a versatile actor, wanted to avoid being pigeonholed in period dramas and maintaining his reputation as a leading man. The role of Rhett Butler, though enticing, could have limited his career opportunities and led to a perception as a romantic hero, a type of character that he felt constrained by.

Contract Issues

At the time, Gable was under contract with Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer (MGM), a commitment that required significant time and dedication. The film Gone with the Wind was a massive project, demanding a substantial commitment from the actor. Gable was hesitant about taking on a long-term project, especially considering his current contractual obligations to the studio.

Personal Circumstances

Gable’s personal life added another layer of complexity to his decision. His first wife’s recent death had left him emotionally vulnerable, and he was likely feeling the weight of personal obligations and responsibilities. These personal circumstances may have influenced his decision and added to his reluctance to take on a major role at that time.

Ultimately, Gable Changes His Mind

Despite his initial hesitation, Gable was eventually convinced to take the role. MGM, recognizing the significance of the project and the potential impact it could have on Gable’s career, employed a combination of incentives and persuasion. The studio offered a substantial bonus of fifty thousand dollars to Gable, a sum that he needed for personal reasons, which likely played a crucial role in his decision.

h2:

As Gable stated, the novel Gone with the Wind was a runaway bestseller, and people's imaginations were deeply invested in the characters and story. Audiences had formed strong opinions about Rhett Butler, and Gable was aware that if he could not live up to these expectations, the backlash would be significant. The novel's popularity and the public's preconceived notions made the role even more daunting.

Another Reason for the Declination

Another reason for Gable's initial reluctance was his previous experience with a film about Irish politician Charles Stewart Parnell. The biopic was a significant disappointment for Gable, and he was hesitant to tackle another costume drama, fearing a similar outcome. This factor added to his reluctance to pursue the role of Rhett Butler, a period piece.

Ultimately, Gable's Decision

Despite these concerns, Gable was eventually persuaded by his girlfriend, Carole Lombard, to accept the role. Her encouragement, combined with the studio’s strategic approach and incentives, helped Gable overcome his hesitance. The decision to take on the role of Rhett Butler would prove to be one of the most iconic performances in film history, cementing Gable's status as an enduring film legend.

Clark Gable, with his signature charisma and performances, ultimately proved not only that he was capable of embodying the complex and nuanced character of Rhett Butler but also that he was capable of evolving his acting career beyond his previous typecasting. His decision to accept the role, though initially hesitant, would redefine his legacy in the world of cinema.