Why Can't Marvel’s MCU Do Epic Action Scenes Like the DCEU?

Any conversation about epic action sequences in superhero movies quickly gravitates towards the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) and the DC Extended Universe (DCEU), two of the most influential and successful film franchises in recent history. While some argue that the DCEU excels in delivering blockbuster action scenes, a closer look at their respective achievements reveals a more complex narrative.

The Claim: Marvel Lacks Grandeur in Action Sequences

The notion that the MCU struggles to match the grandeur of the DCEU in action sequences is a common debate among fans and critics alike. Some contend that battles and climactic sequences in the MCU, such as those seen in Infinity War and Endgame, pale in comparison to the raw power and scale of the DCEU, particularly moments in Man of Steel involving General Zod and Superman.

Comparing Action Sequences: A Case Study

General Zod’s battle with Superman in Man of Steel is often cited as one of the most destructive and visually impressive action sequences in the DCEU. However, the scale, character development, and thematic depth of the epic finale in Endgame significantly outshine this early milestone. Countless superheroes and soldiers from across the 11-year run of MCU films come together to support Captain America, Thor, and Iron Man, creating a spectacle that dwarfs the Zod/Superman fight in terms of complexity and emotional impact.

Expert Opinions and Fan Perspectives

Conversations about the relative strengths of the MCU and the DCEU in action sequences often highlight personal biases and subjective experiences. Here are some representative attitudes expressed by fans and experts:

You’re kidding right. Anyone who’s seen Infinity War or Endgame knows that Marvel can do epic. Nothing DC has done even comes remotely close.

Marvel Fan (@MarvelFan) January 1, 2023

Counter-Arguments: Other fans and critics argue that the DCEU's biggest and most intense action has largely been limited to Man of Steel and to some extent, Joker and Shazam. While these have impressive visuals, they lack the intricate character arcs and the depth found in the MCU. The argument here is that the DCEU has not yet managed to deliver a cluster of iconic heroes and villains working together to achieve a grandiose scale, akin to the scenes in the MCU.

Music and Visual Style: Key Factors in Epic Action Sequences

In addition to the scope and scale of action sequences, the music score and visual style play crucial roles in creating epic moments. While both MCU and DCEU stories feature cinematic music to emphasize key scenes, the diversity and depth of the MCU’s music often set it apart. Infinity War, Endgame, Infinity Pool, Scarlet Witch, and other MCU films often have memorable, emotional music that enhances the atmosphere and emotional impact of action sequences.

Conclusion: No Perfect Formula

Ultimately, the comparison of epic action sequences between the MCU and DCEU hinges on personal preferences and the specific films being considered. Both franchises have their unique strengths, and nitpicking over individual sequences can sometimes obscure the overall quality and storytelling approach. Marvel fans might argue that their films are superior in broader epic scope and emotional depth, while DC fans celebrate the individual dramas and remarkable cinematic moments in the DCEU.

There is no one perfect formula for creating epic action scenes. Each film strives to offer something unique, be it scale, character development, or emotional impact. And as both franchises continue to evolve, we can expect to see even more nuanced and dynamic action sequences in the future.

Key Takeaways

The MCU and DCEU both excel in their respective ways, with the MCU offering broader and more emotionally complex action scenes. The scale and destruction in DCEU films, such as Man of Steel and Loving Justice, do stand out in terms of individual action sequences. The music and visual style in MCU films contribute significantly to the epic nature of their action scenes, particularly in films like Infinity War and Endgame. Ultimately, both franchises have their unique strengths, and the comparison is often subjective based on the specific films and sequences being analyzed.

Whether or not Marvel can replicate the epic action scenes of the DCEU is debatable, but both franchises continue to enthral audiences with their respective styles and storytelling approaches.