Why Aren't Modern Films Considered Amongst the Greatest of All Time?

Films are more than mere escapism or entertainment; they are cultural artifacts that reflect the essence of their times. The changing zeitgeist affects how we perceive and value contemporary works compared to older classics. Today, we have had more time to live with and critically analyze films from earlier eras. As time passes, older films often gain new respect and recognition. However, modern films frequently face the challenge of achieving the same level of esteem. This article delves into why modern films are currently underrepresented on lists of the greatest films of all time.

Understanding Film Appreciation Over Time

The relationship between film and cultural appreciation is profoundly temporal. Lists like the BFI Sight Sound have evolved over decades, oscillating between the enduring classics and more recent masterpieces. This evolution showcases the shifting dynamics in film criticism and popular opinions. Critics and audiences alike reexamine older films, finding depth and innovation in them that was initially overlooked. When these classics are revisited, their standing in the pantheon of cinema can rise significantly. Conversely, the quality of modern films is often scrutinized more harshly, especially when they are compared to their predecessors.

Scrutiny and Time

A critical factor in assessing any film's greatness is time. Newer films typically need more time to stand the test of scrutiny. Since they have not yet reached the required maturation period, their true impact and quality may still be in question. In contrast, older films are more readily evaluated based on a range of retrospective analyses. Their legacy is cemented through critical reflection, interpretative rewatchings, and the influence they have on subsequent works. As tastes evolve and film techniques advance, older films often become even more revered, while new films may struggle to gain similar respect.

The Comparison Factor

One of the primary reasons modern films struggle to be among the greatest of all time is the proliferation of films in the modern era. Older film classics were released in a context where more films did not exist, allowing for greater uniqueness and innovation. With the rise in film production, it becomes increasingly difficult for new films to stand out. Each modern film is weighed against a vast number of precedents, making it harder to introduce fresh ideas and innovations. This constant benchmarking makes it challenging for modern films to achieve a legendary status, especially considering the rapid pace of technological and thematic developments in cinema.

Nostalgia and Cultural Familiarity

Another significant factor is the time that has passed since a film's release. Older films have had more time to develop a cultural presence and a nostalgic impact. The longer a film is in the public consciousness, the easier it becomes to appreciate its nuances and merits. Modern films, in contrast, are often judged more strictly due to their relative novelty. They may face the challenge of competing with the shock of the new, rather than being appreciated in context. Nostalgia plays a powerful role in film appreciation, as older films often evoke a sense of time and place that modern films may not be able to fully replicate.

The Role of Marketing and Trailers

The marketing strategies used for modern films can also impact their perceived quality and appeal. In the age of digital marketing, modern films frequently reveal key plot points and twists through trailers. This early exposure can spoil the experience for viewers, diminishing the surprise and excitement. In contrast, older films often relied on teasers that hinted at the story without revealing too much. This teasing approach allowed audiences to fully appreciate the plot twists for the first time within the film, enhancing overall enjoyment. Modern films, due to more extensive marketing, may miss out on this element of surprise and storytelling integrity.

Conclusion

The relative scarcity of modern films on greatest films lists is a complex interplay of time, comparison, and audience expectations. While some modern films certainly have the potential to join the ranks of the greatest, many are still evolving and gaining recognition over time. With more time, modern films may find their rightful place amongst the pantheon of cinematic masterpieces. The evolution of film appreciation is ongoing, and the legacy of modern cinema will no doubt continue to shape and be shaped by cultural shifts.