Why Aragorn Chose Arwen Over Legolas or Gimli: An In-Depth Analysis

Many readers and critics have pondered over why Aragorn ultimately chose to marry Arwen Undómiel over his fellow Rangers, Legolas and Gimli. The complex interplay of love, duty, and destiny often leaves a lasting impression on the minds of readers. This article aims to delve deeper into the motivations behind Aragorn's decision, focusing on J.R.R. Tolkien's original narrative instead of film adaptations.

Understanding Aragorn and Arwen's Relationship

In the vast tapestry of The Lord of the Rings and The Silmarillion, Aragorn and Arwen form a unique partnership. Unlike the passionate yet tumultuous union of Beren and Luthien, Arwen and Aragorn's romance is marked by a deep respect and unwavering devotion. Beren’s love for Luthien involves a willingness to go through any hardship, even into the gates of hell. This romantic ideal is absent in Aragorn and Arwen's story. Instead, their love is a quiet, steadfast commitment.

Arwen is a Benghazi Elf, part of the Noldorin Elvish race, while Aragorn is a human of Númenórean descent. Their love story is rich in symbolism, representing the fusion of human and elfin worlds, a concept that has fascinated scholars and readers alike. In the original narrative, Arwen gets to make her decision after Aragorn has already succeeded or failed his journey. Unlike Luthien, who leaves her father Moriolos to follow her love, Arwen remains in Rivendell, allowing Aragorn the space he needs for his mission.

The Differences and Similarities

The relationship between Aragorn and Arwen bears striking similarities to that of Beren and Luthien but with its unique nuances. Arwen remains in Rivendell, obeying her father's wishes and supporting Aragorn from afar. She does not venture beyond Rivendell to assist the Fellowship directly, except through moral support and sending a banner to Aragorn. This decision reflects her profound respect for her father's authority and her own princely duties.

When Aragorn dies, it is significant that Arwen calls the gift of Men “bitter,” a stark contrast to Luthien who is grateful for every second spent with Beren. Arwen’s resignation and implied suicide after Aragorn’s death reflect a profound sense of loss, unlike Luthien’s enduring gratitude and joy. This emotional weight underscores the depth of their relationship and the complexities of their decision-making processes.

The Rational Behind the Decision

Aragorn marrying Arwen was not a matter of reversing historical lines as some might suggest. Aragorn’s love for Arwen was indeed unwavering. He was 20 when he first met her, and they made a commitment to marry at the age of 49. This 68-year journey of undying love is depicted in Tolkien's works as a testament to the depth and longevity of their relationship. Aragorn's first encounter with Arwen left him in awe, and over the centuries, his love for her remained constant.

Contrary to the popular assumption, Aragorn is not gay. His love for Arwen was a one-time promise, a commitment based on a deep emotional and spiritual connection. Eowyn, with whom Aragorn had a brief but intense romance, did not arise as a contender for his heart. Aragorn's love for Arwen was seen as a sacred union, a destiny that he deeply believed in, willing to pursue despite the challenges and obstacles.

Conclusion

The choice of Aragorn to marry Arwen was a complex and thoughtful decision rooted in the enduring themes of love, loyalty, and destiny. It is not merely a romantic ideal, but a depiction of a deep, abiding love that transcends time and circumstances. Aragorn's and Arwen's relationship, much like that of Luthien and Beren, is a celebration of selfless devotion and unwavering commitment.

Keywords: Aragorn, Arwen, Legolas, Gimli, Tolkien