Why ‘The Battle of the Five Armies’ Might Not Get A Remake and Why Kili and Tauriel Can’t Be Together

Many fans of The Hobbit franchise have expressed their desire for a potential remake of the third installment, The Battle of the Five Armies (BoFA). While it is understandable to have such thoughts, particularly because certain aspects of the movie adaptation diverged significantly from J.R.R. Tolkien’s original source material, the likelihood of such a remake is slim. This article delves into the reasons behind why a remake might not happen and why characters like Kili and Tauriel cannot be together despite fan expectations.

Peter Jackson's Intentions and The Hobbit's Adaption

One of the main reasons for the unlikelihood of a remake is the personal intentions of Peter Jackson, the director of the entire The Hobbit trilogy. Jackson has explicitly stated that he has no desire to revisit or rework these movies. The The Battle of the Five Armies, in particular, was the final film in the series, and Jackson has little interest in retooling a trilogy that is already complete.

Comparing The Hobbit and The Book

Another significant factor is the substantial differences between the book and the films. The movies, particularly the second and third installments, were criticized by many fans and critics alike for their heavy padding with extraneous material. These additional scenes and storylines were not considered improvements to the original source material. A potential remake, if it were to happen, would have to address these issues while also staying true to the original story and tone. This would be a challenging task, especially given the tight association between the movie and book versions.

The Role of Tauriel and Kili’s Characterization

Finally, the incorporation of characters like Tauriel and the nature of Kili’s interactions with her are key factors. Tauriel is a creation of Peter Jackson’s and does not exist in the original book. Her character was introduced to add a layer of complexity and depth to the story, particularly through the lens of a female perspective in a male-dominated world. As a dwarf and a male protagonist, Kili’s relationship with an elf like Tauriel, while romantic, is not aligned with the source material. The characters of Kili and Tauriel both died in the book, making it challenging to justify their reunion in a potential remake.

Why You Might Want a Remake

While this may be disappointing for fans of Kili and Tauriel, there is a silver lining. If the goal of a remake were to bring the story closer to the original book, then a remake would indeed be a positive development. However, as most movie remakes aim to update or enhance the story, the need for a The Battle of the Five Armies remake is questionable. Existing movie adaptations typically capture the essence of the source material without the need for complete overhaul.

The Alternative: Fan Fiction and Adaptations

For those who are deeply invested in the Kili-Tauriel relationship, there is always the option of reading fan fiction or watching fan films. There are numerous online communities, including dedicated forums and platforms such as , where one can find a plethora of stories and films where these characters have romantic entanglements. Fans often create their own versions of these stories to fulfill their fantasies and wishes for these characters.

In conclusion, while the desire for a The Battle of the Five Armies remake and the Kili-Tauriel relationship are understandable, the current climate of the The Hobbit franchise strongly suggests that these outcomes are unlikely. However, the world of fan fiction and creative adaptations offers a world of possibilities where these wishes can be fulfilled.