Who's the Biggest Mary Sue: Luke Skywalker, Anakin Skywalker, or Rey?

Star Wars, a galaxy far, far away, is filled with countless characters, each with their own unique strengths and flaws. However, some of them might be perceived as having characteristics that make them stand out in an overly positive and unrealistic manner, often referred to as a Mary Sue. In this article, we explore the pros and cons of three iconic Jedi characters - Luke Skywalker, Anakin Skywalker, and Rey - and determine if any of them can be labeled as the biggest Mary Sue.

Luke Skywalker: The Relatable and Resilient Hero

Pros:

Starts as an ordinary farm boy and transforms into a powerful Jedi. Exhibits considerable growth throughout his journey, facing significant challenges and setbacks. Has relatable flaws such as impatience and naivety, making him more human and relatable.

Cons:

Some argue that his rapid mastery of the Force and combat skills, particularly in Return of the Jedi, could be seen as an overreach.

Anakin Skywalker: The Tragic and Complex Protagonist

Pros:

Anakin is a deeply complex character, riddled with flaws such as anger, fear, and attachment issues, which ultimately lead to his tragic downfall. Experiences significant and compelling character development, especially in the prequels.

Cons:

Some aspects of his character, particularly in the prequels, may seem contrived, especially his abilities and the events leading to his turn to the dark side.

Rey: The Overly Proficient Protagonist

Pros:

Demonstrates strong skills in the Force and combat from the outset, leading some to label her as a Mary Sue.

Cons:

Critics point to her rapid proficiency in various skills without much training as a key factor in her being perceived as a Mary Sue.

Conclusion: The Mary Sue Controversy

While all three characters have elements that could be interpreted as Mary Sue traits, the conclusion is a nuanced one. It is argued that Anakin is the least likely to be a Mary Sue due to his tragic and complex character arc. Luke, on the other hand, faces significant challenges and growth in each of his films, making him a more rounded and relatable character. Rey, while highly proficient, may indeed exhibit traits of a Mary Sue, but the context of her rapid growth is explained by the fast-paced Legends continuity in which she appears in the Legends series.

Final Thoughts

The debate over whether any of these characters can be labeled as the biggest Mary Sue in Star Wars is ongoing. While the characterization of Obi-Wan Kenobi as a Mary Sue is often dismissed due to his flaws, it is argued that his portrayal can still fit the criterion. However, the argument that Luke is a borderline Mary Sue due to his rapid advancements and relatable flaws is compelling. Ultimately, the complexity and character development of Anakin make him the least likely to be a Mary Sue, followed by Luke and Rey, who may exhibit Mary Sue traits but in different contexts.

Regional and cultural differences may also influence perceptions, with different aspects of these characters resonating with various audiences. Whether a character is a Mary Sue can be subjective, but the discussion provides valuable insight into the balance of strength and realism in character development.