Who Would Win: Quinlan Vos or Obi-Wan Kenobi - EU vs. Disney Canon
Who Would Win: Quinlan Vos or Obi-Wan Kenobi - EU vs. Disney Canon
When it comes to Star Wars, comparing the skills and strengths of different characters can be an intriguing exercise. The question of who would win in a hypothetical confrontation between Quinlan Vos and Obi-Wan Kenobi holds particular interest, especially when considering the background of each character from the EU/Legends continuity and the Disney Canon.
EU/Legends Continuity: Master and Learner
In the Old EU/Legends continuity, the comparison between Quinlan Vos and Mace Windu (Obi-Wan Kenobi has limited direct matchups but is commonly compared to Windu) is quite clear. There was a notable sparring match between them, which gave a clear indication of their relative strengths.
Windu dominated the engagement, barely breaking a sweat while Vos was straining to keep up. Vos was only able to end the sparring match when he became more intense and threatened Windu, but even then, Windu easily ended the fight.
Further evidence of Vos's inferiority includes his defeat by Sora Bulq, who was a comrade of Mace Windu and a pioneer of the Vapaad style. Despite giving Sora Bulq a tough fight, Vos required everything he had to win. Even Count Dooku, a formidable opponent, easily defeated Vos in a battle where the latter was not at his best.
The most damning evidence is the fact that Windu consistently faces stronger opponents and holds up better in battles. Vos would never be portrayed as capable of matching Count Dooku or Darth Sidious in the EU continuity. His only recorded duel with Dooku was a loss, and he was defeated twice in his time with the Jedi Order.
Disney Canon: A Shift in Power Dynamics
Things change significantly in the Disney Canon. In the novel Dark Disciple, Quinlan Vos is portrayed as a powerful warrior who becomes Dooku's personal enforcer and eventually defeats him in a duel. This storyline enhances Vos's reputation and places him in a much stronger light compared to his EU counterpart.
Vos's transformation in the Disney Canon makes him a more formidable opponent than in the EU continuity. He is now a direct threat to Obi-Wan Kenobi, especially given that Kenobi is often compared to Dooku as a masterlightsaber expert. However, even with this shift, Obi-Wan Kenobi would still likely be portrayed as the winner in the end, leveraging his mastery of lightsaber combat and strategy.
Conclusion
The comparison between Quinlan Vos and Obi-Wan Kenobi, whether in the Old EU/Legends continuity or the Disney Canon, reveals a significant power dynamic. In the EU, Vos is consistently portrayed as inferior, while in the Disney Canon, his power has been enhanced, making him a more challenging opponent.
Key Takeaways:
Windu in the EU/Legends continuity is clearly more powerful than Vos, while in the Disney Canon, Vos has a better chance but Obi-Wan Kenobi still holds the upper hand. Vos's character development in the Disney Canon ensures he is a more formidable opponent, but his ultimate defeat by Obi-Wan Kenobi is a strong possibility. The scaling chain between characters suggests a hierarchical ranking, with Dooku and Sidious being the ultimate opponents for both.Regardless of the Canon, both Quinlan Vos and Obi-Wan Kenobi are respected Jedi figures, each with a unique set of skills and strengths.