Who Would Win: Ace or Whitebeard in a Battle?

Welcome to a classic debate in the world of One Piece that has sparked fierce discussions among fans: Would Ace win over Whitebeard? This question has been debated many times, with arguments supporting both sides. Let's explore the factors involved in the fight between these two iconic characters.

Ace's Background and Abilities

Ace, a member of the Whitebeard Pirates, is a formidable character known for his fiery fists, the Burning Arm, and Rumble Ball techniques. At the time of his battle with Blackbeard, Ace was already a commander-level fighter. However, his strength and skills were not enough to overshadow the immense power and experience of one of the Yonko.

Whitebeard's Supremacy

Whitebeard, one of the most powerful captains in the New World, outclasses Legendary Pirates like Ace. His Ex-Almighty Hellsinger technique and unparalleled experience give him a significant advantage. He defeated Ace and brought him aboard his ship, where Ace challenged him daily for 100 days. Even after this grueling contest, Ace admitted defeat, showing the immense power gap between them.

Exhaustive Analysis

Power Level:

While Ace was strong, his power level was far from that of Yonko like Whitebeard. The difference in power could be compared to the One Star Admiral Base of Kaido defeating Shanks in a single shot. Ace, though at the commander level, could not match the raw strength and immense power of Whitebeard.

Experience:

Whitebeard's vast experience gave him an edge. He had fought numerous battles and honed his skills for many years. Ace, despite his courage and strength, was still learning and adjusting to his new captain's expectations.

Physical Superiority:

Whitebeard's physical superiority was evident, as he outmaneuvered Ace in physical confrontations. This physical dominance also played a crucial role in their final engagement.

Alternative Perspectives

Zeref Dragneel:

Zeref, the powerful sorcerer with Death Magic, could potentially outclass both Ace and Whitebeard. His immortality and advanced skills give him an upper hand. While Zeref is skilled and powerful, Whitebeard's abilities and age are considered factors that could tilt the balance back towards him.

Perspective from a Fan:

One fan argues that they refuse to watch the show due to dislike for Luffy, but still believes Zeref would win against Whitebeard. This shows the subjective nature of such debates. The fan's journey to watch other shows like Naruto despite years of trying to watch One Piece highlights their unique perspective on anime.

Conclusion

While Ace displayed incredible strength and determination, the overwhelming evidence points towards Whitebeard's victory. Whitebeard’s power, experience, and physical superiority make him a formidable opponent. Zeref, though powerful, has to face the challenges of age and mortality that Whitebeard doesn't.