Who Should Have Robert Chosen as Hand of the King Instead of Ned?

As long as Lord Stark reigns, Robert Baratheon's choice for the Hand of the King remains unchanged. Cersei Lannister's hand in poisoning Robb may change this dynamic, but for now, any proposed Hand would need the confidence and support of both the North and the nobility. With Robb too young and wary of Stannis, Robert's focus shifts towards his childhood friends or those who can offer him the necessary support and connections.

Choosing Potentially Suitable Candidates

It's worth considering Bronze Yohn Royce, with whom Robert has a long-standing relationship dating back to his time as Old Arryn's ward. Renly might be an option but only as a last resort due to their strained relationship. Renly is not close to Robert, making it likely that he would submit Mace Tyrell to fill the position, hoping that Mace could win over Robb. Dorne and Stormlands are clearly not viable choices, and while a Stormlander might seem plausible given Hoster Tully's declining health, Robert's trust in the Ironborn is a significant factor. It can be argued that unless Robert is bewitched to the point of irrationality, he would not choose Jaime Lannister or Tywin Lannister for this sensitive role, nor would he entrust the position to the Westermen.

Considering Otto Hightower as a Model

However, my personal opinion leans towards a candidate closer in nature to Ser Otto Hightower. To understand my reasoning, we must consider the critical needs Robert faced during his reign - a wife to produce heirs, gold, and a capable Hand to handle the duties Robert himself despised, such as financial administration and judging cases.

Here are the key attributes that Otto Hightower embodied:

Rich House Hightower: A wealth generated through trade, making him one of the richest houses in Westeros, confirming his potential to provide the necessary funds. Marriage to a Noble: Otto's connection to the Lannisters through Allicent, Queen of Meereen, ensuring that he had a noble wife who could potentially produce heirs for Robert. Administrative Skills: Otto was already a capable Hand, which means he had the experience and shrewdness to handle the royal duties that Robert found tiresome.

While Otto had these key strengths, it is also noteworthy that Otto's son, King Viserys I, managed to produce heirs successfully through his wife, ensuring that Robert had no complaints regarding succession. Allicent's commitment and desire for her sons to rule would likely prevent any incestuous relations, thereby solidifying the legitimacy of the line.

Final Evaluation and Recommendations

Besides Old Arryn, the options available to Robert are limited. Therefore, a candidate similar to Otto Hightower would be ideal. Hoster Tully, though cunning and with a capable daughter, lacks the administrative prowess that Otto demonstrated. Tywin Lannister, despite his wealth and ability, is tarnished by his reputation and his daughter's indiscretion. Rickard Stark might have been an option, but his available resources were insufficient for Robert's needs.

Mace Tyrell might suddenly emerge as a capable administrator, making him a viable contender. Leyton Hightower, with his wealth and daughters, could also be a promising choice, but only if he manages to prioritize administrative duties over magical pursuits. If I were in Robert's position, my preference would be for Tywin under the condition that he retains Jaime Lannister at Casterly Rock and manages his daughter Cersei effectively, ensuring she remains faithful and obedient.

In conclusion, while the choice of the Hand of the King is fraught with complexities, a candidate reminiscent of Otto Hightower appears to be the most logical and ideal choice for Robert Baratheon, ensuring the stability and prosperity of the realm.