Who Has a Longer Lifespan: Amazons DCEU or Asgardians MCU?

When it comes to comparing the lifespans of characters in the DC Extended Universe (DCEU) and the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU), the Amazons and the Asgardians stand out. Both races are known for their extraordinary longevity, but which one truly outlives the other?

Immortality and Longevity in DCEU

The Amazons in the DCEU universe, like those depicted in Wonder Woman, are blessed with extended lifespans. This is particularly evident in the novelization of the movie, where it clearly states that they are immortal on Themyscira. While they are not immune to natural causes of death, the Amazons have lived for centuries on their island, which grants them a form of immortality.

It is worth noting that while Amazons have been alive for approximately 25 millennia before the War of the Gods, some characters like Antiope and Menalippe seem to distort our understanding of their age. This discrepancy highlights the inconsistency in the portrayal of their true ages. Nonetheless, official sources clearly make them immortal on their island, at least.

Extended Lifespan of Asgardians in MCU

The Asgardians in the MCU, such as Thor and Loki, are characterized by their extended lifespans. They are essentially immortal, aging much more slowly than humans. Thor, for instance, claims to be over 1,500 years old, as referenced in Thor and Avengers: Age of Ultron. This dosage of immortality is further reinforced by the periodic consumption of the Golden apples of Idunn, which prevent their aging significantly beyond adulthood.

While not all Asgardians mentioned in the movies possess the Golden apples, the consumption of these apples has been consistently depicted as a means to achieve this remarkable longevity. As a result, Asgardians can live for thousands of years, a feat that sets them apart from other characters in the MCU and DCEU.

Immortality vs. Extended Lifespan

The core difference lies in the nature of their immortality. Amazons are technically immortal on their iconic island, but they can still die from natural causes or other external factors. Asgardians, on the other hand, are essentially immortal; while they may age, their lifespan is significantly longer than that of humans.

The inconsistency in character portrayal becomes particularly evident when comparing the appearances of characters. For instance, Hippolyta and Antiope seem to look significantly older than other Amazons, much like their counterparts in Thor. This inconsistency challenges the claim of immortality and adds a layer of complexity to the perceived longevity of these characters.

Furthermore, the Asgardians seem to be consistently depicted as extremely long-lived, with their extremely slow aging process when they reach adulthood. While they are not truly immortal like the Amazons, they are certainly more durable. Odin's age, for example, convincingly demonstrates his status as a powerful and ancient deity, which contrasts with the seemingly youthful appearances of characters like Antiope and Menalippe.

Conclusion

In conclusion, while both Amazons and Asgardians have extended lifespans that greatly exceed that of humans, Asgardians have a longer and more distinctive form of longevity. Their unique ability to age slowly through the consumption of the Golden apples of Idunn sets them apart and makes them truly remarkable among characters in the MCU and DCEU. The Amazons, while blessed with an extended lifespan, are subject to the limitations of natural aging and death, whereas Asgardians can live for thousands of years, essentially continuing their existence without the fear of aging.

Ultimately, both races are fascinatingly immortal in their own right, contributing to the rich and diverse universe of these cinematic universes. However, if we focus strictly on their actual lifespan, the Asgardians likely outlive the Amazons by a considerable margin.