Who Deserved the Throne Most in Game of Thrones: A Comprehensive Analysis

Game of Thrones is a sweeping tale of politics, power, and destiny. In this intricate web of characters, the debate over who rightfully deserved the Iron Throne is one of the most contentious. Two prominent contenders often discussed are Daenerys Targaryen, a figure driven by justice and power, and Lyanna Stark, a character whose innocent nature could potentially shift the narrative of the series.

The Case for Daenerys Targaryen

Daenerys Targaryen

Daenerys Targaryen emerges as a powerful contender for the Iron Throne. Her character is multifaceted: she is a leader, a liberator, and a warrior. Daenerys Targaryen has been central to the series' overarching themes of redemption, justice, and the rightful rule of dragons. Her journey from a vulnerable slave girl to a queen with three dragons—Drogon, Rhaegal, and Viserion—paints a vivid picture of growth and transformation.

Her Charisma and Leadership

Daenerys is known for her charisma and her ability to unite people under her banner. She has a knack for inspiring loyalty and trust in her followers. Her Dragon Drogon, in particular, symbolizes her powerful connection to the dragons, which are revered in Westeros. Her intelligence and strategic thinking often set her apart in critical moments of the series, making her a formidable leader.

Her Advocacy for the Common People

A significant aspect of Daenerys' character is her compassion and care for the common people. Unlike many rulers before her, she views her subjects as equals in the struggle for justice and freedom. This approach sets her apart from other self-interested or power-hungry leaders, drawing genuine admiration and support from her followers.

Her Conflicts with Jon Snow

The character of Jon Snow, a Stark and Targaryen by blood, has a complex relationship with Daenerys. Jon's loyalty to the Starks and his moral compass often clash with Daenerys' focus on power and control. However, adding to this conflict is Jon's successful murder of Daenerys, which is often seen as a betrayal. His choice to marry Daenerys and promise to rule with her as the Dragon Queen would have created a unique and powerful partnership, enhancing the political landscape of Westeros.

No Children

One of Daenerys' potential shortcomings is her inability to produce children. This lack of an heir to the Targaryen line has often been criticized. However, her strategic marriage with Jon, which would have resulted in 450 Targaryens, could have filled the world with Valyrian Targaryens and restored power to the dragons. This idea, while grand, adds an element of sheer fantasy to the narrative.

The Case for Lyanna Stark

Lyanna Stark

Lyanna Stark, sister of Ned Stark, is another contender for the Iron Throne. As the heir to the Iron Throne, promised to Robert Baratheon, and with her family's legacy and support, she possesses strong claims to the throne. Lyanna's character, while less prominent in the main narrative, offers an alternative perspective on leadership and justice.

Promise to Robert Baratheon

Lyanna was promised in marriage to Robert Baratheon, ensuring a peaceful transition of power. This promise is a significant factor in her potential claim to the throne. Had she lived, her relationship with Robert might have provided a less tumultuous path to the Iron Throne, focusing more on unity and stability rather than power struggles and political intrigue.

Innocence and Suffering

Lyanna's story is one of innocence and tragic suffering. Her abduction by the Crown Prince Rhaegar Targaryen not only took away her life but also disrupted the political landscape of Westeros. This narrative of an innocent victim crying out for justice adds emotional depth to her story. Her death could have been a turning point in the series, potentially changing the narrative towards one of reconciliation and unity.

Conclusion

The debate over who deserved the Iron Throne in Game of Thrones remains intensely personal and emotional. Daenerys Targaryen and Lyanna Stark both present compelling arguments for their rightful claim to the throne. Each character brings unique strengths and challenges to the narrative, making their struggles and triumphs a testament to the complexity of power and destiny in the world of Westeros.

Keywords: Game of Thrones, Daenerys Targaryen, Lyanna Stark, King or Queen