Which Star Trek Cartoon Reigns Supreme: The Original Animated Series, Lower Decks, or Prodigy?

When it comes to determining which Star Trek cartoon is the best, the answer largely depends on your personal preference for comedy or drama. If you prefer a humorous series, Lower Decks undoubtedly stands out. However, if you crave a more serious and deep-set Star Trek experience, Prodigy might be the best fit. Meanwhile, the Original Animated Series (TAS) offers a unique blend, but it struggles to match the quality and thematic depth of its modern counterparts.

Best at What?

The Original Animated Series (TAS) was best known for being an extension of the original series. While it featured interesting storylines, it was often overshadowed by the other two series in terms of quality and impact. TAS attempted to connect with the golden era of Star Trek, but it frequently fell short, failing to capture the essence of its predecessors effectively.

Lower Decks is recognized for its lampshading parody of the NBC era of Star Trek (TNG, DS9, Voyager), with a bit of TOS and TAS thrown in. It offers a comedic take and provides a perfect platform for drinking games, as it turns viewing into an endless hunt for Easter eggs. This show is designed to entertain and provoke laughter, even if it sometimes borders on being absurd.

Prodigy, on the other hand, excels as a show made specifically for kids, providing a unique perspective within the Star Trek universe. Its primary strength lies in its ability to simplify and modernize the complexities of the Star Trek universe, making it accessible to a younger audience. However, it falls short in providing the depth and nuance that the other two series offer.

Personal Opinions

The Original Animated Series was never a favorite during its initial release and hasn't improved with age. The plot devices, such as insubordinate lower-ranking individuals often being right against higher-ranking figures, often seemed contrived. Additionally, its frequent references to other Star Trek series, while amusing, can feel forced and lessens the impact of the series as a standalone entity.

Lower Decks has its share of criticisms. While many appreciate its humor, the show occasionally descends into what seems like sheer nonsense. The character of Mariner, Captain Tendi's daughter, displays actions that would likely result in her being expelled from Starfleet for insubordination. Other aspects, such as the innocuous hologram of Kathryn Janeway, seem like an unnecessary attempt to connect with earlier series, complicating what could otherwise be a straightforward and enjoyable show.

However, it's Prodigy that stands out positively. While it didn't start as popular, viewers soon warmed to its unique approach to the Star Trek universe. Although the Janeway hologram character is viewed critically, it doesn't detract from the overall experience. Prodigy successfully provides a fresh perspective, focusing on the younger generation of Starfleet personnel while maintaining the core essence of Star Trek's ideals.

Conclusion

In summary, the choice between these three Star Trek cartoons depends on personal taste and preference. Lower Decks shines in comedic lampshading and playing with the existing Star Trek universe, making it a standout for fans of humor. Prodigy excels in providing an accessible and engaging experience for a younger audience, blending humor with vibrant storytelling. Meanwhile, The Original Animated Series (TAS) offers a nostalgic extension with episodes standing out, but overall, it lags behind in terms of entertainment and depth.